Live data from Hacker News

Scientists brew cannabis using modified beer yeast

nature.com

11–20 of 81 posts

Re: Scientists brew cannabis using modified beer yeast

#11

As someone in this industry, I doubt this will become a reality. The real problem is cost. When you use yeast, you have to supply the energy for the entire system. When you grow a plant, you get free energy from the sun. The cost savings are hard to beat. Nicotine extracts aren't made from yeast either. That should be a big warning flag for the business sides of these cool projects.

How much is grown in actual sunlight? Isnt most all of it in greenhouses under lamps?

Mixed lighting greenhouses are common because you have a better final product, more control over the environment, and less risk of contamination from nearby farms that are using banned pesticides. There is still quite a bit of sungrown but it requires the right climate. Typically sungrown is only suitable for manufactured products.

Re: Scientists brew cannabis using modified beer yeast

#12
post #6

As someone in this industry, I doubt this will become a reality. The real problem is cost. When you use yeast, you have to supply the energy for the entire system. When you grow a plant, you get free energy from the sun. The cost savings are hard to beat. Nicotine extracts aren't made from yeast either. That should be a big warning flag for the business sides of these cool projects.

That only holds true for the legal market though?

Depends, greenhouses are pretty common too, but yes, in general, you wouldn't want someone seeing what you're growing. I find it unlikely though that these funded startups are targeting the underground market.

Re: Scientists brew cannabis using modified beer yeast

#13
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How much is grown in actual sunlight? Isnt most all of it in greenhouses under lamps?

Mixed lighting greenhouses are common because you have a better final product, more control over the environment, and less risk of contamination from nearby farms that are using banned pesticides. There is still quite a bit of sungrown but it requires the right climate. Typically sungrown is only suitable for manufactured products.

As it becomes more regulated, I personally see this as less of an issue for quality.

That being said, growing with yeast is only good for manufactured products.

Re: Scientists brew cannabis using modified beer yeast

#14

As someone in this industry, I doubt this will become a reality. The real problem is cost. When you use yeast, you have to supply the energy for the entire system. When you grow a plant, you get free energy from the sun. The cost savings are hard to beat. Nicotine extracts aren't made from yeast either. That should be a big warning flag for the business sides of these cool projects.

How much is grown in actual sunlight? Isnt most all of it in greenhouses under lamps?

A lot of the market is shifting over to outdoor. Quality is slightly worse but so much cheaper.

If you're talking about manufactured products that the yeast would compete with, it's pretty much all outdoor.

Re: Scientists brew cannabis using modified beer yeast

#15

As someone in this industry, I doubt this will become a reality. The real problem is cost. When you use yeast, you have to supply the energy for the entire system. When you grow a plant, you get free energy from the sun. The cost savings are hard to beat. Nicotine extracts aren't made from yeast either. That should be a big warning flag for the business sides of these cool projects.

You can't grow yeast with sunlight?

Re: Scientists brew cannabis using modified beer yeast

#16
post #15

As someone in this industry, I doubt this will become a reality. The real problem is cost. When you use yeast, you have to supply the energy for the entire system. When you grow a plant, you get free energy from the sun. The cost savings are hard to beat. Nicotine extracts aren't made from yeast either. That should be a big warning flag for the business sides of these cool projects.

You can't grow yeast with sunlight?

Yeast doesn't photosynthesize. You can use solar power, but then you have big capital costs.

Re: Scientists brew cannabis using modified beer yeast

#17

As someone in this industry, I doubt this will become a reality. The real problem is cost. When you use yeast, you have to supply the energy for the entire system. When you grow a plant, you get free energy from the sun. The cost savings are hard to beat. Nicotine extracts aren't made from yeast either. That should be a big warning flag for the business sides of these cool projects.

Two years back they synthesized the both halves of the steps for creating morphine using yeast.

If you feed the yeast sugar, which is made from sunlight it will be worth it if the yields are high enough.

Re: Scientists brew cannabis using modified beer yeast

#19

As someone in this industry, I doubt this will become a reality. The real problem is cost. When you use yeast, you have to supply the energy for the entire system. When you grow a plant, you get free energy from the sun. The cost savings are hard to beat. Nicotine extracts aren't made from yeast either. That should be a big warning flag for the business sides of these cool projects.

What would be some good (economically viable) applications of this tech?

Re: Scientists brew cannabis using modified beer yeast

#20
post #3

THC and CBD is kind of meh. The real fun (for perverse values of fun) is when someone starts making heroin starter that can reliably turn sugar into enough opiate to risk an overdose. And then bootleg biologics and other patent drugs, I would totally buy a yeast that let me make my own Humira and let me control the supply; even if possessing it meant a hefty prison term.

They did that a while back: https://engineering.stanford.edu/magazine/article/stanford-r...
Post reply on HN