Live data from Hacker News

Google Voice for iPhone Released

googlevoiceblog.blogspot.com

11–20 of 79 posts

Re: Google Voice for iPhone Released

#11
post #9

I'm struck that it appears to do very little local caching. In that sense it feels like a highly polished web app, always at the mercy of an available network. Also, it's iPhone-only. Following the direct download link from an iPod or iPad yields an error. Guess I'm sticking with Boxcar for iPad push notifications.

Guess I'm sticking with Boxcar for iPad push notifications.

Same here, except using Notifo.

Re: Google Voice for iPhone Released

#12
post #7

It's ironic that Apple might have changed their app store rules to allow a Google product (GV) into the app store in order to counter another Google product (Android)

My understanding is that this change in policy was directly in response to pressure from the EU and FTC probes.

Re: Google Voice for iPhone Released

#13
This is great - but you still have to be in the app to make a phone call (doesn't integrate with the native iPhone phone app well). Does anyone know if the Android version has tighter integration?

I'd like to not have to remember to launch the app to return a call and use the native SMS app to send from my GV number. Is this possible with the Android version?

Re: Google Voice for iPhone Released

#15

This is great - but you still have to be in the app to make a phone call (doesn't integrate with the native iPhone phone app well). Does anyone know if the Android version has tighter integration? I'd like to not have to remember to launch the app to return a call and use the native SMS app to send from my GV number. Is this possible with the Android version?

The Android version of Google Voice integrates with the native dialer and SMS apps.

Re: Google Voice for iPhone Released

#16
Overall the polish of the app seems a little lacking but the fact that push notifications are finally available makes it the service itself actually usable on an iPhone. I'm not amazed but certainly a happier person than I was yesterday.

Re: Google Voice for iPhone Released

#17
post #15

This is great - but you still have to be in the app to make a phone call (doesn't integrate with the native iPhone phone app well). Does anyone know if the Android version has tighter integration? I'd like to not have to remember to launch the app to return a call and use the native SMS app to send from my GV number. Is this possible with the Android version?

The Android version of Google Voice integrates with the native dialer and SMS apps.

Tks - that might be enough reason to switch to Android actually.

Re: Google Voice for iPhone Released

#19
post #10
post #9

I'm struck that it appears to do very little local caching. In that sense it feels like a highly polished web app, always at the mercy of an available network. Also, it's iPhone-only. Following the direct download link from an iPod or iPad yields an error. Guess I'm sticking with Boxcar for iPad push notifications.

The "no caching" effect is much less pronounced with fast app switching. Are you on iOS 3.x? Also, in my experience, there are often weird consistency errors in the App Store when something new is rolling out. (I could only see it on my Mac for a while before it appeared on my phone.) Try again in an hour.

I'm on 4.1. I noticed the caching behavior after seeing that the text and voicemail views start with no data loaded, even after viewing the inbox. Forcing the app to exit zeroed out all three views.

Loading data is pretty fast on wifi, and the app is certainly nice to look at, but not taking any advantage of local persistence seems to push the web-centric worldview a step too far.

Post reply on HN