Live data from Hacker News

Would you still pick Elixir in 2019?

github.com

11–20 of 246 posts

Re: Would you still pick Elixir in 2019?

#15
Could someone give a more concise reason for using Elixir? I have a "rule of 3" for checking out things - the third time I hear it mentioned and it seems interesting, then I'll go check it out.

Elixir is past 3 times - so I will check it out for sure! - but this article didn't seem to actually say anything (seemed more like a PR piece that was trying not to be technical, and the main argument appeared to be "well, it's not javascript!").

The part that actually talked about Elixir listed some Pros that didn't seem that unique. What's the "killer feature" of Elixir - or is it just a combination of "good features"?

Re: Would you still pick Elixir in 2019?

#17
The JavaScript Fatigue argument is not good. There's simply no data that backs it and nobody is forced to use new libraries only because they use JavaScript.

I've seen third party dependencies churn on Elixir as well (packages that are no longer maintained or alternatives that are better) - I think it's an inherent problem with using dependencies and has nothing to do with the programming language in which those dependencies are written.

> As a developer I just want to get on with my work, not have to read another Hackernoon post on how everything from last week is obsolete because XYZ framework

My recommendation is that you don't read Hackernoon. This seems like a very ineffective way to level up your developer skills.

Edit: I agree that Elixir is very nice and would pick it over JavaScript for backend heavy applications without thinking. I just don't think this argument makes any sense in that context.

Re: Would you still pick Elixir in 2019?

#19

Elixir just really nice. I gave it a shot again and it is super smooth experience nowadays. Distillery, mix, iex https://github.com/aws-samples/aws-lambda-elixir-runtime The only downside is that the out of the box performance is subpar for http services but it is still acceptable.

Cowboy measures its latency in microseconds, what bottlenecks are you running into specifically?

I assume perf comment is in relation to AWS Lambda, for which the Elixir example they've put up is severely below par perf wise

Re: Would you still pick Elixir in 2019?

#20
I keep wanting to be hyped about elixer but the performance benchmarks confuse me. If you look at the tech emperor benchmarks[1] phoenix makes the list at #46 registering 16% of the performance of the top framework. I'm willing to sacrifice performance for readable maintainable code but it just surprises me that its that slow.

Anyone know whats going on there?

1. https://www.techempower.com/benchmarks/#section=data-r17&hw=...

Post reply on HN