Live data from Hacker News

What Left-Handedness Reveals About How the Brain Works (2014)

brainpickings.org

11–20 of 75 posts

Re: What Left-Handedness Reveals About How the Brain Works (2014)

#11
post #2

"For Southpaws themselves — the affectionate term for lefties ", yeah maybe in the US but not where I'm from. Anyway, I write left handed and hold a pool cue left handed (and also I think I'm correct in saying this: I would hold a rifle left handed), but in every other way that I can think of, I am right handed. I've always thought that was weird, I mean at least compared to others. Anyone else have similar experienc…

Everything right handed (I'm good at drawing), except tin/can opening, there the right hand holds and the left one applies force.

But I'm a clear left footer, I kick better and control force better with my left foot.

Re: What Left-Handedness Reveals About How the Brain Works (2014)

#12
post #2

"For Southpaws themselves — the affectionate term for lefties ", yeah maybe in the US but not where I'm from. Anyway, I write left handed and hold a pool cue left handed (and also I think I'm correct in saying this: I would hold a rifle left handed), but in every other way that I can think of, I am right handed. I've always thought that was weird, I mean at least compared to others. Anyone else have similar experienc…

left: - write - pool cue - brush teeth - scissors - spoon - fork right: - throw - punch - tennis/ping pong - knife i've always seen it as left=precision, right=force for me

That's pretty close to how I do things and I've tended to view the dichotomy similarly. To add to the comment, when batting I'm more comfortable right handed and when kicking I prefer my right foot. I've also grown accustomed to using scissors and mice right handed out of necessity (though one might also argue that scissors frequently involve power). What's odd to me is that I often don't know which hand I'm going to prefer for a task until I try it.

Reading this thread, it's interesting to see that this may actually reasonably common. I don't think I've met anyone else who works this way before, and I realize that this sub-thread is rather self-selecting. Still, it's an existence proof that there's more than one of us.

Re: What Left-Handedness Reveals About How the Brain Works (2014)

#13
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I write, eat, hold a pool cue, golf club, and rifle left-handed but play guitar and hockey right-handed (among other things). Most of my life, my vocabulary defined either “left-handed” or “right-handed” people, where I’d consider you and I left-handed but with right-handed adaptations. (“A lefty living in a right-handed world”) But maybe “mixed handed” is a more accurate term.

Interesting... I'm pretty sure I hold a golf club right handed, but I didn't play much and it was a long time ago so I'm not sure, but I used to play with a friend who was definitely left handed, and he was different to me and everyone else in this respect. I play guitar right handed as well. I've described myself as ambidextrous before, but that's probably incorrect, but it raises the question for me, if that means…

Perhaps "cross-dominant" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cross-dominance) [which I just came across] is a better term for people like us. I don't view myself as ambidextrous because I'm definitely not equally good with both hands. Rather, handedness for me is strongly preferential based on the task.

Re: What Left-Handedness Reveals About How the Brain Works (2014)

#14
post #2

"For Southpaws themselves — the affectionate term for lefties ", yeah maybe in the US but not where I'm from. Anyway, I write left handed and hold a pool cue left handed (and also I think I'm correct in saying this: I would hold a rifle left handed), but in every other way that I can think of, I am right handed. I've always thought that was weird, I mean at least compared to others. Anyone else have similar experienc…

left: - write - pool cue - brush teeth - scissors - spoon - fork right: - throw - punch - tennis/ping pong - knife i've always seen it as left=precision, right=force for me

I also mostly follow this pattern also. As I imagine throwing with my left arm and right arm, the left arm feels a bit "numb" comparatively, like my brain doesn't have as many neurons devoted to controlling it or reading information from it. I can't describe it very well. I wouldn't imagine anything unique in that, and a left armed person could just as easily feel that imagining doing those things with their right arm. It just feels odd to pay attention to the difference in how my brain processes both sides.

Re: What Left-Handedness Reveals About How the Brain Works (2014)

#15
Left: write, eat, brush teeth

Right: throw

Both: tennis, ping pong, hit a baseball, play pool, play football (not sure if that counts).

I went to high school with a guy who was the same, but in reverse (write right, throw left).

My dad's 100% left handed, so I assumed I just copied him -- since my hand writing is so poor I always thought of myself as a learned left hander, but according to the chart in the article I'm actually more left handed than right handed, strange.

Well, I tell people I'm right handed since that's my dominant hand in sports. Definitely wouldn't strike anyone out throwing left handed :)

Re: What Left-Handedness Reveals About How the Brain Works (2014)

#16
post #2

"For Southpaws themselves — the affectionate term for lefties ", yeah maybe in the US but not where I'm from. Anyway, I write left handed and hold a pool cue left handed (and also I think I'm correct in saying this: I would hold a rifle left handed), but in every other way that I can think of, I am right handed. I've always thought that was weird, I mean at least compared to others. Anyone else have similar experienc…

I write, eat, hold a pool cue, golf club, and rifle left-handed but play guitar and hockey right-handed (among other things). Most of my life, my vocabulary defined either “left-handed” or “right-handed” people, where I’d consider you and I left-handed but with right-handed adaptations. (“A lefty living in a right-handed world”) But maybe “mixed handed” is a more accurate term.

  but play guitar and hockey right-handed
It's normal that one shoots right in hockey when one is left-handed (hence the rarity of right shooters). It's counterintuitive when going from years if baseball to hockey for the first time.

Re: What Left-Handedness Reveals About How the Brain Works (2014)

#17
I'm left handed and have been studying Chinese for about 6 months, for 2 hours per day. Out of curiosity, I decided to learn writing Chinese characters with my right hand (also because I thought it was cool to be able to write English with my left hand while writing Chinese with my right hand at the same time). I'm in my forties for additional context.

I've discovered the following things:

* I've always had a moderate degree of social anxiety. But, after a couple of months, I noticed a substantial calming effect when I wrote with my right hand. This bled over into my life in general, and I am much less socially anxious, and more easily able to face anxiety rather than run from it when I need to.

* I able to write Chinese very quickly with my right hand but still not as quickly as my left hand, even though I have had far less practice writing with my left hand. I also discovered I can write English with my right hand nearly as well as Chinese, even though I didn't practice this.

* I recently booted up a videogame called "Getting over it", which requires intense hand/eye coordination. I haven't played the game in over a year, and did it exclusively with my left hand at the time, played for about 30 hours, I think, giving up around half way through (to the part with the very steep ladder after the boxes, where the infamous "shortcut" is, for the people who have played the game). To my amazement, I was able to get to the exact same place with my right hand after only playing for an hour or so! I'm also was able to use chopsticks with my right hand with little practice, as well as brush my teeth quite competently after very little effort.

* After the 2 month mark, I sometimes slipped into a mental state where I could "watch" my right hand write the characters, as if I wasn't in control, and some other entity was controlling it. Now, I'm able to do induce my mind to do the reverse, watching my left hand write, as if controlled by some other entity. I don't know what to make of this.

* In general I feel smarter in some ways. I've noticed a big spike in new ideas for solving problems that I don't think I would have had before. I do a lot of programming on project ideas that I find interesting, and I've found I'm a lot better able to see when a plan of attack isn't working, and abandon it before falling down a rabbit hole, whereas before I would lose focus on the general task, and spend far too much time working on approaches to solving a problem that weren't working. I suppose this could be the placebo effect, or an effect of learning a new language in general. But I thought it was interesting.

---

So, one thing I got out of the above is that it seems as though learning coordinated, dexterous movements are all that is needed to perform well at a variety of tasks with one's non-dominant hand, even if one has little or no practice at a specific activity. I also have the feeling that I've "woken up" a part of my brain that was dormant before.

Also, here is probably a dumb thought, as I am not very knowledgeable about AI, so take this for what it's worth. Based on the above, I had a thought about how the brain works. I was thinking about a hierarchy of neural networks, where the top level networks could switch the inputs of the lower ones.

It seems that if the brain worked similarly to how neural networks work, I would have to have some sort of an ability to do this, or how could I have been able to do so well at the "Getting over it" videogame, as well as write English so well with hardly any practice at the two activities?

It also fits well with the idea of using memory as planning, or creating a blank NN to model something, and putting it in place of the outside world as inputs to two already trained NN's. That NN could be trained to manipulate both so that the same results would be received as when they were running against the outside world. In this way, the connected NN could begin to model the real world and plan strategies without having an outside NN to work with.

Re: What Left-Handedness Reveals About How the Brain Works (2014)

#18
post #2

"For Southpaws themselves — the affectionate term for lefties ", yeah maybe in the US but not where I'm from. Anyway, I write left handed and hold a pool cue left handed (and also I think I'm correct in saying this: I would hold a rifle left handed), but in every other way that I can think of, I am right handed. I've always thought that was weird, I mean at least compared to others. Anyone else have similar experienc…

left hand: hand-write, soccer (kick with left foot), tooth brush, scissors, ping-pong, billard cue right hand: computer mouse, handball (throw with left hand), gun-shooting?, guitar, mini-golf, hockey, baseball

Except for baseball (where a pure lefty would also bat left handed), you're almost entirely left handed (i.e. do the same as pure lefties and righties do).

Unless I'm misunderstanding the guitar bit, assume you mean fret with your right hand. If it's the other way around that's pretty cool, and I would think highly unusual, to fret with the hand that you don't write with.

Actually, now I'm totally confused, I write with my left and fret a guitar with my left, which might not be normal :)

Re: What Left-Handedness Reveals About How the Brain Works (2014)

#19
post #3
post #2

"For Southpaws themselves — the affectionate term for lefties ", yeah maybe in the US but not where I'm from. Anyway, I write left handed and hold a pool cue left handed (and also I think I'm correct in saying this: I would hold a rifle left handed), but in every other way that I can think of, I am right handed. I've always thought that was weird, I mean at least compared to others. Anyone else have similar experienc…

I write and do all other stuff requiring dexterity with my left, but I use my right to operate a mouse. I can use my left as well, but I learned to use my right hand for convenience.

I can mouse equally well with either hand but how often do you find a mouse on the left side of a keyboard? Keyboards themselves are arguably left-handed devices, influencing the decision to mouse with the right further. Similarly, I 10-key right-handed. Many things I do right-handed are not preferences but just learned responses to how the world works.
Post reply on HN