Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

An FAQ for Hacker News?

news.ycombinator.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–19 of 19 posts

Re: An FAQ for Hacker News?

#11

Post by dangoldin »

sant0sk1 wrote: post #8
maneesh wrote: post #6

Would you say An FAQ or A FAQ? Not to be mean, just not sure---cause pronounced it sounds like 'an' but spelled looks like 'a'

"an" is used before words starting with a vowel sound. Not words starting with a vowel character. This is a common mistake. Since FAQ is an acronym, the "F" here does not sound like your average "F". Phonetically it could be represented as "EFF". While "an FAQ" looks strange, it is grammatically accurate.

Well that depends on how you pronounce FAQ. As soon as words like that get colloquial, they are pronounced as one word instead of as a list of letters (fak vs ef-ay-que).

Re: An FAQ for Hacker News?

#14

Post by slapshot »

dangoldin wrote: post #11
sant0sk1 wrote: post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"an" is used before words starting with a vowel sound. Not words starting with a vowel character. This is a common mistake. Since FAQ is an acronym, the "F" here does not sound like your average "F". Phonetically it could be represented as "EFF". While "an FAQ" looks strange, it is grammatically accurate.

Well that depends on how you pronounce FAQ. As soon as words like that get colloquial, they are pronounced as one word instead of as a list of letters (fak vs ef-ay-que).

The New York Times style guide is a handy way to tell: If the Times puts periods between the letters ("A.C.C." for the basketball conference) then it's to be pronounced as individual letters. If the Times puts no periods between the letters ("NATO" for the treaty organization) then it's to be pronounced as a word. That decision is then used to figure out whether there's an "an" in front of it.

The beeb (BBC) works in a similar way. Things that are spelled out are put in all caps ("ACC") and things that are pronounced are put with only a leading capital ("Nato").

Of course, that's just the journalism wonk in me speaking.

Re: An FAQ for Hacker News?

#15

Post by epi0Bauqu »

hernan7 wrote: post #13

Yeah, please add that "what music do you program to" question to the FAQ if you're so kind.

Done. Here's the link for all interested: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=132026

Note (to all reading this) that it is a wiki so feel free to add anything I missed (or delete anything that sucks). I doubt there are many false positives, but there may be a bunch of false negatives.

I plan to batch update it weekly (probably on Mondays) for the previous week.

Re: An FAQ for Hacker News?

#16

Post by pdubroy »

slapshot wrote: post #14
dangoldin wrote: post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well that depends on how you pronounce FAQ. As soon as words like that get colloquial, they are pronounced as one word instead of as a list of letters (fak vs ef-ay-que).

The New York Times style guide is a handy way to tell: If the Times puts periods between the letters ("A.C.C." for the basketball conference) then it's to be pronounced as individual letters. If the Times puts no periods between the letters ("NATO" for the treaty organization) then it's to be pronounced as a word. That decision is then used to figure out whether there's an "an" in front of it. The beeb (BBC) works in…

Don't you mean the B.B.C.? Or are we calling it the beebuk now? ;-)

Re: An FAQ for Hacker News?

#17

Post by slapshot »

pdubroy wrote: post #16
slapshot wrote: post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The New York Times style guide is a handy way to tell: If the Times puts periods between the letters ("A.C.C." for the basketball conference) then it's to be pronounced as individual letters. If the Times puts no periods between the letters ("NATO" for the treaty organization) then it's to be pronounced as a word. That decision is then used to figure out whether there's an "an" in front of it. The beeb (BBC) works in…

Don't you mean the B.B.C.? Or are we calling it the beebuk now? ;-)

Look at the example of the BBC's style guide. If you're using the BBC guide, then things that are all-cap are said using letters. If we wanted to call it the "beebuk" then it'd be "Bbc" (like "Nato").

We just need all high school teachers to find time between teaching basic literacy to teach kids one style guide for these sorts of things.

Post reply on HN