Live data from Hacker News

Brave Browser is taking the web by storm

hackernoon.com

11–20 of 29 posts

Re: Brave Browser is taking the web by storm

#11
post #10

My problem with Brave is that the BAT incentivizes publishers to grab as much of my attention as possible. More attention, more money. If Brave becomes successful, expect the internet to become even more addictive and abusive of human psychology.

In what way is that different than the current state of affairs?

Re: Brave Browser is taking the web by storm

#13
post #10

My problem with Brave is that the BAT incentivizes publishers to grab as much of my attention as possible. More attention, more money. If Brave becomes successful, expect the internet to become even more addictive and abusive of human psychology.

In what way is that different than the current state of affairs?

Not at all. This is portrayed as a way of fixing the incentive structure of the web by making people pay for content, but it only fixes part of the problem. Time tracking is not the same as users making an active choice about what contributes value to their lives (e.g., choosing to pay for a subscription). I would hate to see this compensation mechanism become widespread.

Re: Brave Browser is taking the web by storm

#14
As someone who works in a similar space to what Brave/BAT is trying to do... I would like to point out that it’s very easy to sign people up to receive payments in your scheme.

It’s another thing to (1) get users to actually use your system the way you want them to and (2) get publishers to base their revenue model, at least in part, around your system.

I am not really impressed by these numbers because they do not include any usage statistics of BAT itself and there are no examples of it actually helping publishers.

That said, they are setting out to do something very difficult so we should respect what progress they have made.

Re: Brave Browser is taking the web by storm

#16

The browser itself is pretty great - it exactly what I want - Chromium without the spyware and a decent user interface.

To voice the opposite opinion: if I could have the Brave payment system as a plugin to Safari or Firefox I would install it in a heartbeat.

I don't like Chrome, nor care for Brave as a browser. I use Safari for my daily browsing, or Firefox on Windows. And I really like Brave's system for supporting content creators, it's miles ahead than everything else IMO.

Re: Brave Browser is taking the web by storm

#17
post #12

Why use this? Just give it time, something will arise from this that will have terrible ramifications. Either a privacy breach, or malware insertion, or key logging, or hidden coin mining... something. Mark my words.

I don’t understand this. Is this your response to any successful software? It has nothing to do with Brave, and you provide no explanation.

Re: Brave Browser is taking the web by storm

#18
post #10

My problem with Brave is that the BAT incentivizes publishers to grab as much of my attention as possible. More attention, more money. If Brave becomes successful, expect the internet to become even more addictive and abusive of human psychology.

The pay-per-view ad model does the same, but if anything it wastes that attention time.
Post reply on HN