Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What is your most unpopular idea/belief?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 69 posts

Re: Ask HN: What is your most unpopular idea/belief?

#11
Monsanto and Roundup in the modern era are obviously good for the world.

Advertising and marketing are tools, not inherently good or bad.

Being cookied online for the purpose of tracking advertising effectiveness doesn't hurt the end user.

It's so unlikely for obese people to permanently lose weight without extreme surgical or therapeutic intervention that its unethical for doctors to recommend diet and exercise alone as if that recommendation is efficacious.

That should do it.

Re: Ask HN: What is your most unpopular idea/belief?

#12
post #2

Pretty much all of us are massive hypocrites when it comes to Eugenics: it is a taboo subject when applied to populations, yet everyone apart from the insane is looking for a genetically fit partner.

You are right. As proof there's the game of chess.

Re: Ask HN: What is your most unpopular idea/belief?

#14
Based on down-votes here, probably the idea that "taxation is theft".

I also generally disapprove of the idea of nation-states in general, don't believe in borders, and think that private organizations (which could include non-profits, worker owned co-ops, etc.) can (and should) fill most of the roles which are currently filled by "government".

Basically, being a Market Anarchist / Voluntaryist puts me at odds which a lot of people.

Re: Ask HN: What is your most unpopular idea/belief?

#15

Based on down-votes here, probably the idea that "taxation is theft". I also generally disapprove of the idea of nation-states in general, don't believe in borders, and think that private organizations (which could include non-profits, worker owned co-ops, etc.) can (and should) fill most of the roles which are currently filled by "government". Basically, being a Market Anarchist / Voluntaryist puts me at odds which…

Yes, I tend to downvote those sort of statements.

Re: Ask HN: What is your most unpopular idea/belief?

#18
post #11

Monsanto and Roundup in the modern era are obviously good for the world. Advertising and marketing are tools, not inherently good or bad. Being cookied online for the purpose of tracking advertising effectiveness doesn't hurt the end user. It's so unlikely for obese people to permanently lose weight without extreme surgical or therapeutic intervention that its unethical for doctors to recommend diet and exercise alon…

Can I have a tl;dr on what's good about Monsanto?

Also for point 4, do you think it's unethical for doctors to have faith that a patient can persevere through a completely conquerable challenge? Is it kind of like underprescribing for someone who is in pain? I guess in that way I can kind of see what you're getting at.

Re: Ask HN: What is your most unpopular idea/belief?

#19

Based on down-votes here, probably the idea that "taxation is theft". I also generally disapprove of the idea of nation-states in general, don't believe in borders, and think that private organizations (which could include non-profits, worker owned co-ops, etc.) can (and should) fill most of the roles which are currently filled by "government". Basically, being a Market Anarchist / Voluntaryist puts me at odds which…

For good reason: how exactly do you propose to enforce anything if you don't have a government that's allowed to use force? Give everyone a gun and let them shoot anyone they think has wronged them?

Re: Ask HN: What is your most unpopular idea/belief?

#20
post #2

Pretty much all of us are massive hypocrites when it comes to Eugenics: it is a taboo subject when applied to populations, yet everyone apart from the insane is looking for a genetically fit partner.

I disagree: it's the concept of voluntary vs. involuntary decisions. If I look for a genetically fit partner to have kids with, that's my decision, and it's my choice as to what I consider "good" genes (which is arbitrary, after all). If the state does it, then I have no choice, plus I might be getting paired with someone who I don't consider to have "good" genes, or I might not even be allowed to breed at all.
Post reply on HN