Live data from Hacker News

Has a USB memory stick ever failed on you?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 25 posts

Re: Has a USB memory stick ever failed on you?

#12
We had dozens fail.

Than again, I worked on developing embedded USB stacks. Those guys suffered quite a workload (but nothing astronomical).

Mainly: Random data corruption (~90%) Electrical failure - not responding to reset or power-on (~10%)

Re: Has a USB memory stick ever failed on you?

#16
I still have and use my first $49 256mb sandisk. Never had any issues. I now use a 8g U3 sandisk daily for 100% of my tasks. I live on portable apps.

The closest thing to an issue is I have noticed the total storage size has decreased a tiny bit, but this is supposed to be normal. After all with my email client alone I am doing 1000's of overrights and stuff.

Another thing is to always remember to eject the device properly. I have had corruption of files that way, but never any damage to the drive. I backup weekly.

Flash drives are a god send. I cant imagine carrying around compact disks anymore.

Re: Has a USB memory stick ever failed on you?

#18

I still have and use my first $49 256mb sandisk. Never had any issues. I now use a 8g U3 sandisk daily for 100% of my tasks. I live on portable apps. The closest thing to an issue is I have noticed the total storage size has decreased a tiny bit, but this is supposed to be normal. After all with my email client alone I am doing 1000's of overrights and stuff. Another thing is to always remember to eject the device pr…

...also, I own 10 various brands and sizes of flash drives, all work perfect.

Re: Has a USB memory stick ever failed on you?

#19
Plenty of them. One startup I worked at had hundreds of cluster machines booting from USB drives. I'd say one or two failed every month. They were Kingston brand, too. But they got a lot of use (read and write) and there were literally hundreds of them going at a time.

It goes without saying: back up your data. Never trust your data to be stored in just one location.

Mode of failure varied, but it usually manifested itself in the form of a corrupt filesystem. A few wouldn't even show up as a device when plugged in.

Post reply on HN