Live data from Hacker News

Value of "free" customers in a freemium pricing model

news.ycombinator.com

11–15 of 15 posts

Re: Value of "free" customers in a freemium pricing model

#11
They are valuable for several reasons:

1) They may give you feedback 2) You can track + analyze their usage 3) They may refer peers 4) They may become 'paid customers'

In a vacuum, non-paying customers may not be super-valuable. However, if these non-paying users have good experiences with your product/service, it is possible they are adding more value to than they cost.

Remember, the marginal cost (per user) for many web apps is minimal.

Re: Value of "free" customers in a freemium pricing model

#12
You need to figure out what it costs you to support each user, make a ballpark of how many free users will upgrade (it's less than 2% for most sites that share their numbers, including my own W3Counter.com), and do the math to see if freemium will work for you. You might find that you won't be profitable if your cost to support the free user base is more than the paying users can cover at prices they're willing to pay. You can't just make the price arbitrarily high, sometimes freemium really doesn't work for a business.

W3Counter barely gets by as a freemium service. The paying users cover the servers it takes to run the site, but not enough more to pay even a single person's salary. I'm always waiting until service degrades to the point someone starts complaining before I add more hardware, otherwise enough new users wouldn't have started subscriptions to pay for the expansion.

The next service I built, W3ROI, does not offer a free plan. It's harder to build traffic to the site, and there are less people talking about it on blogs and social networks, but each new user it adds pays for themselves. There is never a risk of not being able to afford the hardware to provide a good quality of service.

Re: Value of "free" customers in a freemium pricing model

#13
There are three reasons. You mentioned two of them - word of mouth, and potential conversion to paying in the future. But there's another one too, and that's just the total size of your userbase. Either for bragging rights (we're bigger than competitor X) or for future sale value (the more users you have, the more money you will likely make from a sale/acquisition of your service, even if a lot of them aren't paying for your service) - both are good reasons to offer a free, dumbed down version of your pay service.

Re: Value of "free" customers in a freemium pricing model

#14
Aside from the items you've mentioned you should also consider these items:

Proving your market - Attracting and registering large numbers of people prove it's something people want. If you can't give it away for free, there's a problem. (Good for funding)

User feedback and "The up sell" - With the right features that non-paying customer may be a paying customer waiting to happen. You'll also have collection of emails of people interested enough to try your product, where you can up sell them to paid later. (Good for your product)

Scalability - Testing your product in the real world with real traffic patterns, live servers, and people depending on your service is very valuable. (Good for funding AND your product)

I'm a huge believer in the freemium model. Just don't give the cow away and try to position your premium product where users feel like they are getting real value when they have to take out their wallets.

Re: Value of "free" customers in a freemium pricing model

#15

It depends on the product. In some products, there may be "network effects" where each user benefits by the number of other users in the system-- for example, if Facebook were to adopt a Freemium model, the paying customers would benefit from having the free users in the system. This, of course, is not the case for most apps-- like Dropbox, in the example you chose. For Dropbox, the free customers have costs associat…

Actually, I think Dropbox has a network effect as well. I'm a paying user, but my account is more valuable to me because can share folders and collaborate with free users. Many of them would not use it if it wasn't free (hey, I started with the free service and later upgraded myself), but since its free they have seen how awesome it is and are 1000% more likely to upgrade to a pro plan than if they'd never started using it in the first place. In the mean time, they make my Dropbox account more valuable to me.
Post reply on HN