Live data from Hacker News

State of Washington sues Facebook and Google over failure to disclose spending

techcrunch.com

11–20 of 213 posts

Re: State of Washington sues Facebook and Google over failure to disclose spending

#13
post #10
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Mmm, this is Washington State, not DC

The scapegoating is being done by the left.

These companies were in obvious violation of the law. These proceedings do not require responsibility for the election to be valid.

Re: State of Washington sues Facebook and Google over failure to disclose spending

#16
post #4

Out of curiosity, how does political ad spending work in the US? It seems that TFA hints at the fact that political ad funding is public and requires proper recordkeeping. Does that mean that when someone sees "This message paid by friends of Mr. Foo", one can write to the TV/radio/website and request more information about "friends of Mr. Foo?"

Kinda sorta. Political campaigns and some large organizations are required to report their spending and donations, and, as a separate thing, advertisements may be required to identify themselves. The State of Washington, though, as well as the City of Seattle, have somewhat unusual laws that requires substantially more. They have a law on the books aimed at TV channels and newspapers requiring that all political ad s…

How does an ad seller know whether an ad buy is "political"? Requiring the seller to keep records seems reasonable, but requiring the seller to make records, does not. That is, an ad seller ought not be expected to know which incoming buys are political. That ought to be the responsibility of the buyer/"creatives" to declare.

Re: State of Washington sues Facebook and Google over failure to disclose spending

#17
post #8

... in the latest chapter of scapegoating internet firms for Trump's election.

Washington AG Bob Ferguson has a history of filing activist lawsuits.

Is an Attorney General enforcing the laws of the state "activist"?

Re: State of Washington sues Facebook and Google over failure to disclose spending

#18
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Kinda sorta. Political campaigns and some large organizations are required to report their spending and donations, and, as a separate thing, advertisements may be required to identify themselves. The State of Washington, though, as well as the City of Seattle, have somewhat unusual laws that requires substantially more. They have a law on the books aimed at TV channels and newspapers requiring that all political ad s…

How does an ad seller know whether an ad buy is "political"? Requiring the seller to keep records seems reasonable, but requiring the seller to make records, does not. That is, an ad seller ought not be expected to know which incoming buys are political. That ought to be the responsibility of the buyer/"creatives" to declare.

Because the buyers are all registered political entities: candidates' campaigns, political action committees, etc. It's illegal for a "regular person" to go buy political ads and not register with the state.

Re: State of Washington sues Facebook and Google over failure to disclose spending

#19

I thought campaign contributions could run afoul of Sarbanes Oxley regulation rules, and other incorrect accounting of donations, if they cant even track what they gave, how can they certify the books.

> if they cant even track what they gave

The article is about what they were paid, as advertising platforms, not what they gave.

Re: State of Washington sues Facebook and Google over failure to disclose spending

#20
post #7

How many of the funders breached federal or state mandated limits on spending? I ask, because in the "brexit" circumstances it becomes clear the "leave" campaign eggregiously breached the declared public advertising spending limits through use of indirect/third-party funding channels who did placement in social media.

This isn't strictly illegal in the U.S. due to the Citizens United decision. Because of free speech blah blah blah I can spend an unlimited amount of money for a cause or canidate as long as I don't coordinate with that campaign.
Post reply on HN