Live data from Hacker News

Electron Band Structure in Germanium, My Ass (2001)

pages.cs.wisc.edu

11–20 of 40 posts

Re: Electron Band Structure in Germanium, My Ass (2001)

#11
post #5

" ...by waving your hands and chanting "to first order". " I've found that to be very successful in all walks of life.

Another classic in the same vein as the linked article is http://people.cs.uchicago.edu/~dinoj/scilies.html , which contains this nugget: "Correct to within an order of magnitude." Wrong.

Used to be ok in some branches of astrophysics. Now they know the age of the universe more accurately than any test you’ll get in a hospital. Stay the f—— out of hospitals (and courtrooms).

Re: Electron Band Structure in Germanium, My Ass (2001)

#13
post #9

Virtually everything, and I mean everything in your post was wrong, but I still enjoyed the hell out of it. Laser scientists know that if you use (a well anti-reflection coated) Ge window or lens to transmit a high power CO2 laser beam, slight absorption heats it a little. Heating it a little makes it more absorptive. So it heats a little more. And so forth, until the motherf——r cracks: “thermal runaway.” Guess why?…

> You are going to be a good experimental physicist eventually.

He switched to CS and now gets paid to work on A-list videogames all day: http://pages.cs.wisc.edu/~kovar/cv.html

Edit: Oops, LinkedIn says he's now at Google.

Re: Electron Band Structure in Germanium, My Ass (2001)

#15
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Another classic in the same vein as the linked article is http://people.cs.uchicago.edu/~dinoj/scilies.html , which contains this nugget: "Correct to within an order of magnitude." Wrong.

Used to be ok in some branches of astrophysics. Now they know the age of the universe more accurately than any test you’ll get in a hospital. Stay the f—— out of hospitals (and courtrooms).

It is a joke, but not completely without any connection to reality: Sometimes, in astrophysics, you are happy if you get the order of magnitude correct to an order of magnitude.

Re: Electron Band Structure in Germanium, My Ass (2001)

#16
post #4

I think this is a good deal older than 2007, but my memory could be playing tricks on me. I could swear I had read this when I was studying semiconductors in school, in the early 2000s. Edit: could be I'm thinking of Britney Spears' Guide to Semiconductor Physics, and I read this article later.

Possible, his homepage says it's published on July 2001 in Annals of Improbable Research.

Re: Electron Band Structure in Germanium, My Ass (2001)

#17

Why the experimental points don't have error bars? Is it not possible to use four terminal sensing? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four-terminal_sensing Perhaps the sample is too irregular, but for very low resistance samples using only two terminals never work. Can they use a lock-in amplifier? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lock-in_amplifier When it works, it's like magic. I'm not sure that it is useful here > I atta…

Lock-in amplifiers are indeed great. They essentially shift your signal up in frequency, where you have less background. Here, it might be hard to apply because you would need to modulate the heating. Not impossible, but the maximum frequency is certainly limited.

Part of being a physicist is having a high pain tolerance to non-working hardware. This includes cables.

Re: Electron Band Structure in Germanium, My Ass (2001)

#19
post #13
post #9

Virtually everything, and I mean everything in your post was wrong, but I still enjoyed the hell out of it. Laser scientists know that if you use (a well anti-reflection coated) Ge window or lens to transmit a high power CO2 laser beam, slight absorption heats it a little. Heating it a little makes it more absorptive. So it heats a little more. And so forth, until the motherf——r cracks: “thermal runaway.” Guess why?…

> You are going to be a good experimental physicist eventually. He switched to CS and now gets paid to work on A-list videogames all day: http://pages.cs.wisc.edu/~kovar/cv.html Edit: Oops, LinkedIn says he's now at Google.

Conclusion: Going into physics was the biggest mistake of my life. I should've declared CS. I still wouldn't have any women, but at least I'd be rolling in cash.

Re: Electron Band Structure in Germanium, My Ass (2001)

#20
post #13
post #9

Virtually everything, and I mean everything in your post was wrong, but I still enjoyed the hell out of it. Laser scientists know that if you use (a well anti-reflection coated) Ge window or lens to transmit a high power CO2 laser beam, slight absorption heats it a little. Heating it a little makes it more absorptive. So it heats a little more. And so forth, until the motherf——r cracks: “thermal runaway.” Guess why?…

> You are going to be a good experimental physicist eventually. He switched to CS and now gets paid to work on A-list videogames all day: http://pages.cs.wisc.edu/~kovar/cv.html Edit: Oops, LinkedIn says he's now at Google.

The last line from his CV is a gem:

"Two years experience in swing dancing (east coast swing and lindy hop)."

Post reply on HN