Live data from Hacker News

America has a monopoly problem

thenation.com

11–20 of 199 posts

Re: America has a monopoly problem

#11

Peter Thiel (who works with YC) will tell you that monopolies are good for the world.

Any links you could recommend? I’d like to read more as I disagree strongly.

* Peter Thiel's WSJ article: https://www.wsj.com/articles/peter-thiel-competition-is-for-...

* Criticism: https://medium.com/@petersimsie/why-peter-thiel-is-dead-wron...

* Alternate interpretation of Thiel's intent: https://www.quora.com/Peter-Thiel-claims-that-competition-is...

Re: America has a monopoly problem

#13
This is brilliant. I recently wrote in to my senator about net neutrality. His reply was a breathtakingly convoluted justification of not regulating companies like Comcast because antitrust laws would take care of it. I've never felt so insulted.

Re: America has a monopoly problem

#14
America has a corruption problem. The ability for companies to vertically integrate and essentially make smaller businesses non-competitive can only occur when you don't have to pay the taxes your smaller competitors have to pay and don't have to obey the same laws your competitors have to obey.

We have a systemic corruption problem (manifested in lobbying) coupled with greed on scales we've never seen before. Everything else is just a symptom of that problem.

Re: America has a monopoly problem

#17
post #6

Peter Thiel (who works with YC) will tell you that monopolies are good for the world.

They often are, because companies in highly competitive industries don’t have the excess profits to reinvest in research. Computing as we know it is largely the story of monopolies. Bell Labs bankrolled by the AT&T monopoly. Xerox PARC bankrolled by the Xerox copier monopoly. The Internet bankrolled by the ultimate monopoly (the military). The modern web bankrolled by the Google/Apple duopoly.

Yet all of those monopolies either imploded, had their markets simply dry up, were out-innovated by smaller competitors, or investors just moved onto hotter fads.

The crashing and burning of a big monopoly may very well be a healthy event; but oh the damage they do before then...

Re: America has a monopoly problem

#18

This is brilliant. I recently wrote in to my senator about net neutrality. His reply was a breathtakingly convoluted justification of not regulating companies like Comcast because antitrust laws would take care of it. I've never felt so insulted.

Which senator was this?

Re: America has a monopoly problem

#19
post #6

Peter Thiel (who works with YC) will tell you that monopolies are good for the world.

They often are, because companies in highly competitive industries don’t have the excess profits to reinvest in research. Computing as we know it is largely the story of monopolies. Bell Labs bankrolled by the AT&T monopoly. Xerox PARC bankrolled by the Xerox copier monopoly. The Internet bankrolled by the ultimate monopoly (the military). The modern web bankrolled by the Google/Apple duopoly.

> Bell Labs bankrolled by the AT&T monopoly.

Comparing one very effective and interesting skunkworks lab with the incredible explosion in choices and service in telecommunication, as well as drastically lower prices, that came when the monopoly was broken up?

I think you're demonstrating the anti-monopoly point handily.

Re: America has a monopoly problem

#20
post #6

Peter Thiel (who works with YC) will tell you that monopolies are good for the world.

They often are, because companies in highly competitive industries don’t have the excess profits to reinvest in research. Computing as we know it is largely the story of monopolies. Bell Labs bankrolled by the AT&T monopoly. Xerox PARC bankrolled by the Xerox copier monopoly. The Internet bankrolled by the ultimate monopoly (the military). The modern web bankrolled by the Google/Apple duopoly.

AT&T of course had a strict ban on innovation by third parties on the phone network, up to the "hush-a-phone" case.
Post reply on HN