Live data from Hacker News

Testing disks: Lessons from our odyssey selecting replacement SSDs

bbc.co.uk

11–20 of 78 posts

Re: Testing disks: Lessons from our odyssey selecting replacement SSDs

#11

One of my favourite parts of this article is how Elliot Thomas describes himself as a "Software Engineer". We may be writing software, but without a working knowledge of hardware it's not worth much!

I have barely any knowledge of hardware, but I have built plenty of pieces of software that have helped people.

Re: Testing disks: Lessons from our odyssey selecting replacement SSDs

#12

Great article, easy to follow considering it's far away from my normal domain. I noticed they didn't mention any brands by name though, why is that?

The BBC has a very strong product prominence policy[0] (i.e. avoid naming brands when possible), being government funded is a large driver of this policy. [0] http://www.bbc.co.uk/editorialguidelines/guidelines/editoria... EDIT: fixed policy name and added link

It's a shame this is so selectively applied.

See, for example:

- The constant mention of speaking to people 'over Skype' on the News

- Publicization of Twitter hashtags on Questiontime and other programs

- Hours worth of Top Gear footage (and the entire Arctic Special) that were effectively Toyota Hilux advertisements

Re: Testing disks: Lessons from our odyssey selecting replacement SSDs

#13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I noticed they didn't mention any brands by name though, why is that? As a public service broadcaster in the UK, the BBC must be very careful about naming specific brands and products due to rules laid out in their legal remit (and fear of legal action if from a party that feels unfairly disadvantaged by a competitor getting a good mention or them getting a bad one). This is way Blue Peter always use "sticky backed…

(This is almost too petty a point to reply, but "sticky backed plastic" is a sheet of adhesive transparent film, like you'd use to cover books. I think they probably would have said "sticky tape")

The main UK brand of "sticky backed plastic" was Fablon.

Re: Testing disks: Lessons from our odyssey selecting replacement SSDs

#14
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not Government funded. There's a mandatory TV tax (for TV viewers), the fee of which is set by Government.

You are right, but considering that until recently not paying your TV license was a crime in effect it is government funded; ultima ratio regum and all that...

Stealing my car is a crime too. Today I learned my car is government funded.

Re: Testing disks: Lessons from our odyssey selecting replacement SSDs

#15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I noticed they didn't mention any brands by name though, why is that? As a public service broadcaster in the UK, the BBC must be very careful about naming specific brands and products due to rules laid out in their legal remit (and fear of legal action if from a party that feels unfairly disadvantaged by a competitor getting a good mention or them getting a bad one). This is way Blue Peter always use "sticky backed…

(This is almost too petty a point to reply, but "sticky backed plastic" is a sheet of adhesive transparent film, like you'd use to cover books. I think they probably would have said "sticky tape")

I don't know why you are being downvoted because you are correct. I'd further your post and also point out the correct term to vacuum is still "vacuum". The BBC didn't invent that term like they did "sticky backed plastic".

The radio is often quite amusing when there are guests on there who accidentally slip a brand name. Presenters often then reply with the same rehearsed quote:

    "Other brands of [cola] also exist."

Re: Testing disks: Lessons from our odyssey selecting replacement SSDs

#16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You are right, but considering that until recently not paying your TV license was a crime in effect it is government funded; ultima ratio regum and all that...

Stealing my car is a crime too. Today I learned my car is government funded.

Your argument is non sequitur. If others were required to pay for your car via legislation then you might have an argument.

Re: Testing disks: Lessons from our odyssey selecting replacement SSDs

#17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You are right, but considering that until recently not paying your TV license was a crime in effect it is government funded; ultima ratio regum and all that...

Stealing my car is a crime too. Today I learned my car is government funded.

Property rights are a government-funded right, correct.

The roads your drive on are almost certainly subsidised from beyond the direct taxes you pay on your car and fuel too.

Re: Testing disks: Lessons from our odyssey selecting replacement SSDs

#18
I built my home system early this year using the Samsung 960 Evo 1TB M2. Actual speeds were nowhere near advertised speeds until I enabled write-back cache on the drive, which gave me pause for concern about data persistence reliability. AFAIK the Samsung drivers (as opposed to the MS drivers I originally used) just turn this on without needing to be twiddled in settings.

Just to confirm, I have seen the behaviour described herein, with write-back cached making enormous difference with the Samsung EVO product in particular.

Re: Testing disks: Lessons from our odyssey selecting replacement SSDs

#19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The BBC has a very strong product prominence policy[0] (i.e. avoid naming brands when possible), being government funded is a large driver of this policy. [0] http://www.bbc.co.uk/editorialguidelines/guidelines/editoria... EDIT: fixed policy name and added link

It's a shame this is so selectively applied. See, for example: - The constant mention of speaking to people 'over Skype' on the News - Publicization of Twitter hashtags on Questiontime and other programs - Hours worth of Top Gear footage (and the entire Arctic Special) that were effectively Toyota Hilux advertisements

The constant favourable coverage of Google and Apple, always talking about hipster-friendly Flickr when boring old Photobucket was doing 20x the volume... they apply their rules very selectively....

Re: Testing disks: Lessons from our odyssey selecting replacement SSDs

#20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I noticed they didn't mention any brands by name though, why is that? As a public service broadcaster in the UK, the BBC must be very careful about naming specific brands and products due to rules laid out in their legal remit (and fear of legal action if from a party that feels unfairly disadvantaged by a competitor getting a good mention or them getting a bad one). This is way Blue Peter always use "sticky backed…

(This is almost too petty a point to reply, but "sticky backed plastic" is a sheet of adhesive transparent film, like you'd use to cover books. I think they probably would have said "sticky tape")

They literally did say "sticky-backed plastic" for sellotape, which left me bemused as a nipper
Post reply on HN