Live data from Hacker News

$1,000 per month cash handout would grow US economy by $2.5 trillion, study says

cnbc.com

11–20 of 52 posts

Re: $1,000 per month cash handout would grow US economy by $2.5 trillion, study says

#11
post #7

Do people actually believe this universal basic income nonsense? If money isn't scarce but goods are the goods become proportionally more expensive. Inflation is a thing.

Even if goods become more expensive, if you currently have $0/month, and transition to $1K/month, that is an improvement.

Re: $1,000 per month cash handout would grow US economy by $2.5 trillion, study says

#12
post #7

Do people actually believe this universal basic income nonsense? If money isn't scarce but goods are the goods become proportionally more expensive. Inflation is a thing.

That only happens when the demand for goods increases. The price of core necessities would likely be unaffected, as people already prioritize these items and purchase enough to meet their needs. The cost of entertainment, prepared food and other discretionary spending would likely increase though.

Re: $1,000 per month cash handout would grow US economy by $2.5 trillion, study says

#13
post #2

Halfway through: > These estimates are based on a universal basic income paid for by increasing the federal deficit. As part of the study, the researchers also calculated the effect to the economy of paying for the cash handouts by increasing taxes. In that case, there would be no net benefit to the economy, the report finds. > "When paying for the policy by increasing taxes on households rather than paying for the p…

Well, I suppose that's better than making things a lot worse.

Re: $1,000 per month cash handout would grow US economy by $2.5 trillion, study says

#14

Wait a minute, though: Every adult gets $1,000/month. That's $12,000/year. How many adults do we have? Well, the US population is 326,000,000. Median age is 37, so I'll guess that 3/4 of the population is "adult" (age >= 18). That means that paying this handout will cost $12,000/person * 244,500,000 people = $2.934 trillion. That's... not a net win.

[deleted]

Re: $1,000 per month cash handout would grow US economy by $2.5 trillion, study says

#16
post #2

Halfway through: > These estimates are based on a universal basic income paid for by increasing the federal deficit. As part of the study, the researchers also calculated the effect to the economy of paying for the cash handouts by increasing taxes. In that case, there would be no net benefit to the economy, the report finds. > "When paying for the policy by increasing taxes on households rather than paying for the p…

Printing money would encourage the ad bubble, because the economy would grow based on how much of the basic income consumers spend.

Re: $1,000 per month cash handout would grow US economy by $2.5 trillion, study says

#17
post #5
post #2

Halfway through: > These estimates are based on a universal basic income paid for by increasing the federal deficit. As part of the study, the researchers also calculated the effect to the economy of paying for the cash handouts by increasing taxes. In that case, there would be no net benefit to the economy, the report finds. > "When paying for the policy by increasing taxes on households rather than paying for the p…

I'm a libertarian. I think that the UBI could allow for economic growth based solely on the power it as to eliminate the welfare trap. However, this would only work as a replacement for all welfare, though. It would have to replace welfare, food stamps, social security, etc, with the exception of medicaid and medicare. I support UBI only as a replacement for existing (bad) welfare systems. I think UBI in conjunction…

Hello fellow libertarian.

The problem is that very many welfare recipients get more than $1,000/month per adult. Disabled? Single mother with children? You'll easily get 2x that (including check, food stamps, subsidized housing).

And no one is going to want to take away from the poor.

$1,000/adult/month replacing welfare is an impossibility. We'd have to use much larger numbers.

Re: $1,000 per month cash handout would grow US economy by $2.5 trillion, study says

#18
post #7

Do people actually believe this universal basic income nonsense? If money isn't scarce but goods are the goods become proportionally more expensive. Inflation is a thing.

Sane UBI plans do not change the scarcity of money but use it as a way to re-distribute money from the rich (those with capital making all the money with robots and technology) to those that only have their labor to support themselves (which is getting inferior to technology by the day).

Re: $1,000 per month cash handout would grow US economy by $2.5 trillion, study says

#20
post #2

Halfway through: > These estimates are based on a universal basic income paid for by increasing the federal deficit. As part of the study, the researchers also calculated the effect to the economy of paying for the cash handouts by increasing taxes. In that case, there would be no net benefit to the economy, the report finds. > "When paying for the policy by increasing taxes on households rather than paying for the p…

Tomorrow's headline:

Startups could grow more if they borrowed more money!

Post reply on HN