Live data from Hacker News

Dick's Sporting Goods produces a list of 938 banned words; “dick” is outlawed

m.dickssportinggoods.com

11–19 of 19 posts

Re: Dick's Sporting Goods produces a list of 938 banned words; “dick” is outlawed

#13
post #5
post #4

What's it used for? Usernames/passwords or something?

You can personalize jerseys and sporting goods. https://www.dickssportinggoods.com/products/maxfli-personali...

Ah thanks, I had no idea. Some of these are insanely specific, weird or tame ("soused", "ovum", "dimwit")

Re: Dick's Sporting Goods produces a list of 938 banned words; “dick” is outlawed

#14
post #10

Why would you outlaw 'fat'? This makes no sense.

These are words that they think could cause offense to their customers. Fat can be insulting and unflattering.

What if someone wanted to say "I'd like to reduce my body fat"?

Re: Dick's Sporting Goods produces a list of 938 banned words; “dick” is outlawed

#15
Common stuff. I work for Bazaarvoice; we have "generic" lists of "bad" words, as well as client-specific ones. We use them to automatically reject product reviews, or to at least flag them for human intervention.

You all can probably understand why these lists err on the side of false positive, rather than false negative.

There's also the occasional fun false positive, such as a reply to a review from a client that would include a URL with one of the "bad" words as a URL token: e.g., "To learn how to clean your vacuum, download the manual at www.manufacturer.com/download?product=123&ass=abc" - where "ass" is some abbreviated variable name that ends up causing replies to get rejected.

(There's also some really, really fun words in some of those lists that I have no idea how they got there. My favorite one is actually from a different company that maintains a word list: N.I.P.P.L.E.S. Yes, all capital, with periods in between the words. Highly specific, and I'd love to know what was the original trigger for adding that to the list.)

Re: Dick's Sporting Goods produces a list of 938 banned words; “dick” is outlawed

#16
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

These are words that they think could cause offense to their customers. Fat can be insulting and unflattering.

What if someone wanted to say "I'd like to reduce my body fat"?

Then the submitted content would probably get flagged for manual review, and would be approved.

Re: Dick's Sporting Goods produces a list of 938 banned words; “dick” is outlawed

#17
post #13
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can personalize jerseys and sporting goods. https://www.dickssportinggoods.com/products/maxfli-personali...

Ah thanks, I had no idea. Some of these are insanely specific, weird or tame ("soused", "ovum", "dimwit")

Many were probably added after someone took a screenshot of a hoodie or whatever they were able to create on their online store, and post it to twitter to the amusement of everyone but Dick's marketing/legal departments.
Post reply on HN