Live data from Hacker News

Android Team “Laser Focused” On The User Experience For Next Release

techcrunch.com

11–20 of 40 posts

Re: Android Team “Laser Focused” On The User Experience For Next Release

#11
With the WebOS UI designer and most features you want in the OS, this will be an important step for Android. The OS is stable and mature with 2.2. Actually i like the UI on the Nexus One very much, but i'm sure it can be improved from good to awesome with the team focused on it. Somewhere on Google I/O was a screenshot with Gingerbread on it, but i guess this will change.

edit: very early Gingerbread screens: http://www.sizzledcore.com/2010/05/22/android-3-0-screenshot...

Re: Android Team “Laser Focused” On The User Experience For Next Release

#12
post #8

That's good. Problem: what about Sense and Motoblur? Think HTC and Moto are going to drop them just because the Android UI bas improved? yeah right...

Correct, they will never stop doing it. But they will eventually start seperating it more, letting the user chose to use the standard home screen and dialer for example. Not sure of the Sense UI but it shouldn't be no problem to make it just another (preinstalled) alternate home screen where the user can chose to switch to the standard home.

Also work on the UI side hopefully also means faster portation of those UIs. Not sure why it takes Motorola/HTC/Sony so long to port their versions to the latest Android code, but i guess this can be improved on the Android side of things, too.

Re: Android Team “Laser Focused” On The User Experience For Next Release

#13
post #9
post #3

Now we just need someone to build a phone without vomiting their own crappy interface all over it. The Nexus One is great, but can't we have a bit more choice than 1?

Wanting choice and keeping companies from customizing their product to differentiate them seem to be goals that are at odds with each other. However, I've used a number of android based phones and I still find the Nexus One's interface to be the best and cleanest.

Yeah, I'm not mad at Google, I'm disappointed with HTC, Motorola and Samsung.

Re: Android Team “Laser Focused” On The User Experience For Next Release

#14
The Android Team needs to aim pass the IPhone UX if they plan to win. The Android platform needs to tighten their controls around the UI a little bit more. The very least they can do is make it so that when people look at a smart phone/device, they instantly recognize it as an Android powered device. I think that will help the brand a little bit.

Re: Android Team “Laser Focused” On The User Experience For Next Release

#15
post #7
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, it's more like a gut and redo, while leaving the structural elements alone. And they say they are happy with the structural elements.

I say kudos if they can pull it off. Ignoring the possible meddling of the various device manufacturers, they have their work cut out for them. I want to be optimistic here; it is just I've never seen such re-engineering done before for any OS.

UI redesign will most certainly take place on the homescreen, the launcher, the dialer, etc. In other words: in it's own seperate applications, this wouldn't conflict somewhere because it's done quite frequently. Android is themeable quite nicely, so even changing the standard dialogs from one style to another _should_ work. My own concern here is that some developers probably have written their own UI code and some custom hacks. But we'll see about that.

Re: Android Team “Laser Focused” On The User Experience For Next Release

#16
post #13
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wanting choice and keeping companies from customizing their product to differentiate them seem to be goals that are at odds with each other. However, I've used a number of android based phones and I still find the Nexus One's interface to be the best and cleanest.

Yeah, I'm not mad at Google, I'm disappointed with HTC, Motorola and Samsung.

You're disappointed because HTC, Motorola and Samsung provide choice, or because the choices they provide suck?

I'd like to see some stronger innovation, but that some subset of the choices suck just provides a solid reason to pick the better option. Even a bad example is an example, in that we all learn what doesn't work, and we can cherry pick the best things from a number of different sources. The wider ecosystem in carrier-customized Android interfaces means finding out faster which featuers ones are not strong.

Re: Android Team “Laser Focused” On The User Experience For Next Release

#17
post #3

Now we just need someone to build a phone without vomiting their own crappy interface all over it. The Nexus One is great, but can't we have a bit more choice than 1?

It's particularly easy to install something like CyanogenMod or other custom ROMs on most Android devices (the good ones, at least). That gets rid of things like Sense and puts you back to the stock image, but with possibly better hardware than even the Nexus One.

Re: Android Team “Laser Focused” On The User Experience For Next Release

#18
post #2

I'm more than pleased with how Android looks and behaves on the Nexus One. Obviously it can only get better from here, but I really hope that Google tries to avoid going the exact same route of Apple with their iOS. Apple has a lot of desirable features on the iPhone, but also many quirks that I can never, ever get over. On top of this, I'm not a huge fan of how they're doing multi-tasking, and the introduction of "w…

I think there's some confusion over how Apple is implementing multitasking. Apps continue to run in the background, and when you re-open them you'll be back to where you were. The operating system will begin to terminate the apps when it is low on resources. In addition, there are certain services that work a little bit differently, like VoIP, music in the background, tasks that need extra time to run, etc. As far as I'm aware, this is very similar to the way that Android implements it.

The wallpaper feature is there if you want to use it, but Apple has included some darker pattern wallpapers if you prefer a low key background behind the icons. Of course, one could always whip up a plain black background to use too.

Re: Android Team “Laser Focused” On The User Experience For Next Release

#19
Very exciting to see the major strides they're making. Unfortunately not all the updates are getting rolled out to all users, which makes it harder to get people "selling" the phone to their friends. I've got a G1 Dev phone and I'm still stuck on 1.5-1.6 (or something similarly ancient), so I guess I'm really hoping I can somehow swing an upgrade to a Nexus for myself :/

Re: Android Team “Laser Focused” On The User Experience For Next Release

#20
post #15
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I say kudos if they can pull it off. Ignoring the possible meddling of the various device manufacturers, they have their work cut out for them. I want to be optimistic here; it is just I've never seen such re-engineering done before for any OS.

UI redesign will most certainly take place on the homescreen, the launcher, the dialer, etc. In other words: in it's own seperate applications, this wouldn't conflict somewhere because it's done quite frequently. Android is themeable quite nicely, so even changing the standard dialogs from one style to another _should_ work. My own concern here is that some developers probably have written their own UI code and some…

UI is about how things work first, about styling second. Themes are not going to help you with the former.
Post reply on HN