Live data from Hacker News

Dropbox accounts created after Oct. 2012 won't have a public folder

dropbox.com

11–20 of 133 posts

Re: Dropbox accounts created after Oct. 2012 won't have a public folder

#11
I relied on this "light" publishing for a few things and I'm quite pissed off. I did not notice any notification on this.

To me, this should be done very very visibly and with tons of warnings. I used it to communicate screenshots with details, etc. Now all links are broken and I'm SOL with no viable solution to changing those links from documents, bugs, etc., etc.

Very very very bad!

Re: Dropbox accounts created after Oct. 2012 won't have a public folder

#12
post #7

This was amazingly awesome because: I could teach people how to make a website, and how to have on the internet, in minutes. Having said that, I haven't had that public folder in many many many many many years. So I'm surprised about this announce. If anyone knows a quick way to let anyone do what I described above, please do tell.

Well this isn't suitable for "normal" users but I use SyncThing to sync a folder on my computer to a server running Apache.

Re: Dropbox accounts created after Oct. 2012 won't have a public folder

#13
post #11

I relied on this "light" publishing for a few things and I'm quite pissed off. I did not notice any notification on this. To me, this should be done very very visibly and with tons of warnings. I used it to communicate screenshots with details, etc. Now all links are broken and I'm SOL with no viable solution to changing those links from documents, bugs, etc., etc. Very very very bad!

I have an email notification from Dropbox in December of last year saying this will be disabled.

Re: Dropbox accounts created after Oct. 2012 won't have a public folder

#15
post #2

I was under the impression those where disabled long ago. Tor is always good if you need a quick easy way to publish something without a public IP address

How exactly does Tor replace the ease of publishing something with Dropbox?

I guess he's referring to the fact that you can run a server behind Tor at an onion address without needing to forward any ports.

But that's not really the same problem.

Re: Dropbox accounts created after Oct. 2012 won't have a public folder

#16
post #7

This was amazingly awesome because: I could teach people how to make a website, and how to have on the internet, in minutes. Having said that, I haven't had that public folder in many many many many many years. So I'm surprised about this announce. If anyone knows a quick way to let anyone do what I described above, please do tell.

S3 buckets with the website feature enabled, but you have to pay for usage and I don't know of a way to emulate Dropbox's local filesystem integration with S3... at least not one that's accessible for nontechnical users.

Re: Dropbox accounts created after Oct. 2012 won't have a public folder

#17
post #16
post #7

This was amazingly awesome because: I could teach people how to make a website, and how to have on the internet, in minutes. Having said that, I haven't had that public folder in many many many many many years. So I'm surprised about this announce. If anyone knows a quick way to let anyone do what I described above, please do tell.

S3 buckets with the website feature enabled, but you have to pay for usage and I don't know of a way to emulate Dropbox's local filesystem integration with S3... at least not one that's accessible for nontechnical users.

That's already complicated + not free.

Re: Dropbox accounts created after Oct. 2012 won't have a public folder

#18
post #2

I was under the impression those where disabled long ago. Tor is always good if you need a quick easy way to publish something without a public IP address

How exactly does Tor replace the ease of publishing something with Dropbox?

You just run a web server in a hidden service, it takes less than five minutes to set up. People without for can still see it with onion.to.

Re: Dropbox accounts created after Oct. 2012 won't have a public folder

#19
post #7

This was amazingly awesome because: I could teach people how to make a website, and how to have on the internet, in minutes. Having said that, I haven't had that public folder in many many many many many years. So I'm surprised about this announce. If anyone knows a quick way to let anyone do what I described above, please do tell.

Well this isn't suitable for "normal" users but I use SyncThing to sync a folder on my computer to a server running Apache.

What is the server running Apache? :)

Re: Dropbox accounts created after Oct. 2012 won't have a public folder

#20
post #11

I relied on this "light" publishing for a few things and I'm quite pissed off. I did not notice any notification on this. To me, this should be done very very visibly and with tons of warnings. I used it to communicate screenshots with details, etc. Now all links are broken and I'm SOL with no viable solution to changing those links from documents, bugs, etc., etc. Very very very bad!

Oh, they definitely notified their users. There were emails and warnings in the UI, it was very visible. Really, you can't blame Dropbox there.

However, one can still blame Dropbox for the change itself. I used this on several occasions, including hosting archives for academic publications. No way in hell I can change those links. Maybe that wasn't a wise choice, but at that time it looked like a good way: The link did not give a clue about my identity, making peer review easier, and DB being a well-funded and known internet company those links were surely meant to work forever, cool URLs don't change is something they had to know. Boy was I wrong.

Post reply on HN