Live data from Hacker News

Hydrogen – An advanced drum machine for Linux

hydrogen-music.org

11–20 of 134 posts

Re: Hydrogen – An advanced drum machine for Linux

#13
The interface reminds me a lot of FL Studio (which I currently use on Ubuntu via Wine, works great). Hydrogen looks interesting, but I think most DAWs simply have almost all of these features and far more. That being said, this looks to be FOSS, which I really admire. I'll have to check this out after work.

Re: Hydrogen – An advanced drum machine for Linux

#15
post #9
post #8

Only I hear cracking sound at the end of every beat? Removing pulseaudio helps to shorten it but not completely eliminates.

Pulse/alsa/jack shenanigans make audio production the only thing I still use MacOS for.

Pulseaudio should not even be involved, as the program do not require it. But then it keeps inserting itself into the "conversation" by hijacking any connection to and from Alsa...

Re: Hydrogen – An advanced drum machine for Linux

#16
post #8

Only I hear cracking sound at the end of every beat? Removing pulseaudio helps to shorten it but not completely eliminates.

Define "removing". Pulseaudio is a hard beast to put down.

apt remove pulseaudio pulseaudio-utils then reboot, not really that hard.

Re: Hydrogen – An advanced drum machine for Linux

#17

The interface reminds me a lot of FL Studio (which I currently use on Ubuntu via Wine, works great). Hydrogen looks interesting, but I think most DAWs simply have almost all of these features and far more. That being said, this looks to be FOSS, which I really admire. I'll have to check this out after work.

Most DAWS might have drum machines but most serious users end up using a third party product. The built-in ones are undeniably good but thinks like Kontact/EZDrummer etc. are on another level.

Re: Hydrogen – An advanced drum machine for Linux

#18
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Pulse/alsa/jack shenanigans make audio production the only thing I still use MacOS for.

Pulseaudio should not even be involved, as the program do not require it. But then it keeps inserting itself into the "conversation" by hijacking any connection to and from Alsa...

If it's doing that, you might want to check your ~/.asoundrc, which might be specifying pulse as the default ALSA device.

Re: Hydrogen – An advanced drum machine for Linux

#19

The interface reminds me a lot of FL Studio (which I currently use on Ubuntu via Wine, works great). Hydrogen looks interesting, but I think most DAWs simply have almost all of these features and far more. That being said, this looks to be FOSS, which I really admire. I'll have to check this out after work.

Most DAWS might have drum machines but most serious users end up using a third party product. The built-in ones are undeniably good but thinks like Kontact/EZDrummer etc. are on another level.

Never used Kontact or EZ Drummer, but seems like it would be hard to beat Ableton Live Suite's combo of drumracks and stacking effects per drum sample... Do you have experience with both? Any reason I should look into the former when I've invested in the latter?

edit: Nevermind, after looking at Native's offering (Kontact), I can see it has a lot of advantages for a certain kind of music, but that isn't the music I'm writing...

Re: Hydrogen – An advanced drum machine for Linux

#20
post #9
post #8

Only I hear cracking sound at the end of every beat? Removing pulseaudio helps to shorten it but not completely eliminates.

Pulse/alsa/jack shenanigans make audio production the only thing I still use MacOS for.

Do you use an audio interface? What have you found is supported well by Linux? Saffire Pro 24 + Addictive Drums + Logic is what is really keeping me tied to macOS at home.
Post reply on HN