Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

This site is making readers pass a quiz before commenting

niemanlab.org

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–18 of 18 posts

Re: This site is making readers pass a quiz before commenting

#11

Post by Ntrails »

Cthulhu_ wrote: post #9
kagamine wrote: post #8

I think in some instances, and they only use the quiz on some of the articles, this is a good way to filter the idiots, but on the negative side I wonder how many people forgot the intelligent thing they had to contribute because they had to spend time and mental energy completing a quiz. I hope this doesn't spread beyond serious things for serious people , it is very poor UX to ask users to jump through hoops and sp…

If they forgot the intelligent thing they had to contribute then it wasn't intelligent to begin with - it's more likely to be a knee-jerk reaction. If people read the article properly they'll already have taken more time than would trigger a knee-jerk reaction.

I can lose my train of thought between walking from one room to another. It's got nothing to do with the value of the thought itself - just that I'm easily distracted.

It's highly likely I can recapture the thought by stepping back into the environment in which it occurred (in this case skim re-reading the article I imagine), but honestly I don't tend to comment on ephemeral sites, rather post on communities about commenting. It seems more interesting/useful

Re: This site is making readers pass a quiz before commenting

#12

Post by lithos »

Javagaming.org has one for registration. Normally one of the hard looking programing problems that are easy, or a find the mistake that is keeping the program from running. Enough to look like a hard problem, even though a nonprofessional programmer gets through.

Cut down on uninvested "program for free for me" threads, seo spammers (when those were a thing on forums), and spam.

Re: This site is making readers pass a quiz before commenting

#13

Post by falcor84 »

Ntrails wrote: post #11
Cthulhu_ wrote: post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If they forgot the intelligent thing they had to contribute then it wasn't intelligent to begin with - it's more likely to be a knee-jerk reaction. If people read the article properly they'll already have taken more time than would trigger a knee-jerk reaction.

I can lose my train of thought between walking from one room to another. It's got nothing to do with the value of the thought itself - just that I'm easily distracted. It's highly likely I can recapture the thought by stepping back into the environment in which it occurred (in this case skim re-reading the article I imagine), but honestly I don't tend to comment on ephemeral sites, rather post on communities about co…

>I can lose my train of thought between walking from one room to another.

That's not just you, it's a scientifically studied effect - https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-walking-throu...

Re: This site is making readers pass a quiz before commenting

#14

Post by CodeWriter23 »

kagamine wrote: post #8

I think in some instances, and they only use the quiz on some of the articles, this is a good way to filter the idiots, but on the negative side I wonder how many people forgot the intelligent thing they had to contribute because they had to spend time and mental energy completing a quiz. I hope this doesn't spread beyond serious things for serious people , it is very poor UX to ask users to jump through hoops and sp…

Enter comment, click next, take quiz, click post. Get an answer wrong, your comment is wiped and you have to start over.

Re: This site is making readers pass a quiz before commenting

#15

Post by uabstraction »

kagamine wrote: post #8

I think in some instances, and they only use the quiz on some of the articles, this is a good way to filter the idiots, but on the negative side I wonder how many people forgot the intelligent thing they had to contribute because they had to spend time and mental energy completing a quiz. I hope this doesn't spread beyond serious things for serious people , it is very poor UX to ask users to jump through hoops and sp…

Spreading misinformation on political news through comment sections and social media has become a rampant problem. Most news sites with a discussion feature are so full of toxic and misleading comments that some form of moderation is necessary for healthy discourse. It gets especially bad after a few days when the news wanes, but the trolls keep coming. Anyone digging up an article from a month ago to see the discussion will only find the aftermath of an army of trolls, with all insightful or impartial comments drowned out.

This has been a problem since the dawn of the Internet, and along the way we have seen some interesting approaches at comment moderation (Slashdot is a classic example). Moderation has the potential for abuse, and as such, should be applied reasonably and transparently. That said, I can't blame anyone for searching for new ways to fight trolling and the promotion of blatant ignorance in this day and age.

The New York Times has even resorted to limiting discussions (or not rolling them out to every last article in the first place) and human moderation. It slows down discussion, and it may be subject to censorship, but it goes a long way towards helping both sides have a say in the discussion without it devolving to Youtube quality discourse.

Re: This site is making readers pass a quiz before commenting

#17

Post by kagamine »

uabstraction wrote: post #15
kagamine wrote: post #8

I think in some instances, and they only use the quiz on some of the articles, this is a good way to filter the idiots, but on the negative side I wonder how many people forgot the intelligent thing they had to contribute because they had to spend time and mental energy completing a quiz. I hope this doesn't spread beyond serious things for serious people , it is very poor UX to ask users to jump through hoops and sp…

Spreading misinformation on political news through comment sections and social media has become a rampant problem. Most news sites with a discussion feature are so full of toxic and misleading comments that some form of moderation is necessary for healthy discourse. It gets especially bad after a few days when the news wanes, but the trolls keep coming. Anyone digging up an article from a month ago to see the discuss…

I never said trolling was not a problem or that moderation should not exist, I was looking at the test from a UX pov where it fails quite badly. On the upside, it succeeds for the collective of users who don't have to filter tripe, but for the individual user it fails. Has the site measured how much traffic has dropped off since implementing this 'feature'? NRK afaik don't run ads, at least not a lot of ads, being as they are Norwegian BBC, but I can see this feature being a detriment to page hits. Would be nice to see some statistics on that and similar effects on the users.

Re: This site is making readers pass a quiz before commenting

#18

Post by Ntrails »

falcor84 wrote: post #13
Ntrails wrote: post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I can lose my train of thought between walking from one room to another. It's got nothing to do with the value of the thought itself - just that I'm easily distracted. It's highly likely I can recapture the thought by stepping back into the environment in which it occurred (in this case skim re-reading the article I imagine), but honestly I don't tend to comment on ephemeral sites, rather post on communities about co…

>I can lose my train of thought between walking from one room to another. That's not just you, it's a scientifically studied effect - https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-walking-throu...

Somewhat delayed response - but that's a cool link! thanks :)
Post reply on HN