Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Building a People First Community, a Response to Mark Zuckerberg

medium.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–12 of 12 posts

Re: Building a People First Community, a Response to Mark Zuckerberg

#11

Post by didibus »

grzm wrote: post #3
didibus wrote: post #2

"Human beings are by nature tribalistic." I'd love too see the empirical evidence for this.

References from the Wikipedia article on tribalism would likely be a good starting point. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tribalism Group selection would be another area that might provide some more information on related arguments: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Group_selection

I don't see any empirical data pointing that Humans are tribal by nature in neither of those. The first link just explains the concept, the second is a highly criticised hypothesis.

The article base all its premise on the axiom that we're tribal by nature, and I think while we might all think that makes sense, I've never seen data to indicate we are innately tribal.

Re: Building a People First Community, a Response to Mark Zuckerberg

#12

Post by didibus »

kneel wrote: post #5
didibus wrote: post #2

"Human beings are by nature tribalistic." I'd love too see the empirical evidence for this.

You should check out the entire corpus of written history by homo sapiens. Great empirical evidence in there

I don't know, there's a lot of counter examples in there too. Lots of people jumping ship, immigrating, switching alliance, etc.

There's also examples of multi-tribal membership, like belonging to multiple groups at ounce. Such as your family, your sports team, your city, country, etc, but also things like multi citizenship, mixed race, etc.

You've also got examples of tribes growing massively in size to the point that it's bigger then our social circle. The US is a great example, it's bigger then anyone's social circle, yet people identify at its level and are united within.

I can as easily claim that humans are not inherently tribal, but are inherently lead to organize in ways they believe most beneficial to themselves, which often times leads them to tribes, but not always.

Post reply on HN