Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Thank You and Goodbye, the CyanogenMod Team

plus.google.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–20 of 50 posts

Re: Thank You and Goodbye, the CyanogenMod Team

#11

Post by glkgdswdg »

brianwawok wrote: post #4
vonklaus wrote: post #2

I have read this and another post from CM team. I somehow missed what the main catalyst was for shutting down. Is there a succinct explanation? What happened?

Hard to make money selling a free OS to replace an OS the customer doesn't pay for already?

They weren't targeting users, they were targeting manufacturers (pay them and they'll do the software).

It actually makes sense as a business model, but they messed up by backstabbing their first customer (after contracting with OnePlus, they signed an exclusive contract with MicroMax that no other company can sell cyanogenos in India, which, had OnePlus not made OxygenOS, would have killed them.)

It was probably the stupidest move they could have done, as no company would trust them again, and lost them all the goodwill they had.

Re: Thank You and Goodbye, the CyanogenMod Team

#13

Post by dispose13432 »

lostgame wrote: post #3
vonklaus wrote: post #2

I have read this and another post from CM team. I somehow missed what the main catalyst was for shutting down. Is there a succinct explanation? What happened?

I, too, am kinda left wondering 'what happened?'

They were the darling of custom ROMs before Cyanogen Inc.

When they incorporated, a lot of people hoped it would help sponsor development (while others, suspecting what would happen, forked into OmniRom).

Unfortunately, once they incorporated, the company spokesman (McMaster) went against the whole original culture (they installed bloatware on their phones) and generally spoke without thinking (kill Google, etc.).

Now, they're seen as a weak wannabee Oracle.

Re: Thank You and Goodbye, the CyanogenMod Team

#17

Post by fapjacks »

ajross wrote: post #5
vonklaus wrote: post #2

I have read this and another post from CM team. I somehow missed what the main catalyst was for shutting down. Is there a succinct explanation? What happened?

Not really. Here's what's publicly known: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CyanogenMod#Restructure_and_ce... Honestly it looks to me that they just ran out of runway and dissolved into an internal power struggle, then someone representing the investor side of things came in to shut it all down and recover what could be salvaged.

There was a post on Reddit from one of the former developers warning people to disable updates (not for regular CyanogenMod, but for the commercial devices) because the company was talking about pushing adware of some kind of the devices with an unannounced update.

Re: Thank You and Goodbye, the CyanogenMod Team

#18

Post by notatoad »

Animats wrote: post #15
dispose13432 wrote: post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They have one. It's called LineageOS.

Blah. Sounds like another Linux distro.

I think the boring name is a good sign - Operating systems should be boring. Flashy marketing leads to the sort of drama that killed cyanogen.

Re: Thank You and Goodbye, the CyanogenMod Team

#19

Post by notatoad »

vonklaus wrote: post #2

I have read this and another post from CM team. I somehow missed what the main catalyst was for shutting down. Is there a succinct explanation? What happened?

there's a good summary at the top of this reddit thread: https://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/5kbnfg/cyanogen_in...

Re: Thank You and Goodbye, the CyanogenMod Team

#20

Post by user837387 »

glkgdswdg wrote: post #11
brianwawok wrote: post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hard to make money selling a free OS to replace an OS the customer doesn't pay for already?

They weren't targeting users, they were targeting manufacturers (pay them and they'll do the software). It actually makes sense as a business model, but they messed up by backstabbing their first customer (after contracting with OnePlus, they signed an exclusive contract with MicroMax that no other company can sell cyanogenos in India, which, had OnePlus not made OxygenOS, would have killed them.) It was probably the…

>>It was probably the stupidest move they could have done, as no company would trust them again, and lost them all the goodwill they had.There are plenty of people in the business world that screw so many people, businesses, banks and they still manage to continue doing business. I wish there was a name for it. Madoff is an example: even after people warned others about his business being a scam he still continued doing business until he collapsed on his own. Nobody brought him down, he did it to himself.

The big lie is what they teach us as young kids, that honor actually means something.

Power is might, and if you have it nothing else seems to matter, virtually always.

Post reply on HN