Live data from Hacker News

Ultralight IKEA-Bag Backpack

sandiegomitch.com

11–20 of 136 posts

Re: Ultralight IKEA-Bag Backpack

#13
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

He paid $6 for the bags, so it may have been cheaper this way and/or more convenient.

Oh, it was obviously cheaper. But he spent 25 hours stitching. If I were doing that, I'd spend $25 getting the properties I wanted.

I think it looks pretty cool. And now he has the knowledge of how to make the backpacks without mistakes, so he can move onto more expensive material with confidence.

Re: Ultralight IKEA-Bag Backpack

#14

Interesting as a DIY project, but I would strongly advise not using this for anything where functionality matters (camping, hiking, travel, etc). For just going to work/school it is a great fashion statement, but there are serious concerns 1. no chest strap to help distribute the load. I see a waist strap which is nice, but chest is generally the bare minimum 2. Those seals (stiches) aren't waterproof 3. It is only a…

Obviously this isn't in the same league as a good functional backpack, but that's not the point, is it?

Regarding your first point, I find a waist strap much more important, but then again, with a few more hours of work, a chest strap could easily be added.

Re: Ultralight IKEA-Bag Backpack

#18
Some 20 years ago a homeless friend showed me how to make a backpack out of the fabric of a discarded umbrella.

I wasn't going to rummage through bins for broken brollies, so I bought a new one to break up, which he found immensely amusing.

I wouldn't recommend it, it worked but only if your standards are low enough.

Re: Ultralight IKEA-Bag Backpack

#19

Interesting as a DIY project, but I would strongly advise not using this for anything where functionality matters (camping, hiking, travel, etc). For just going to work/school it is a great fashion statement, but there are serious concerns 1. no chest strap to help distribute the load. I see a waist strap which is nice, but chest is generally the bare minimum 2. Those seals (stiches) aren't waterproof 3. It is only a…

Obviously this isn't in the same league as a good functional backpack, but that's not the point, is it? Regarding your first point, I find a waist strap much more important, but then again, with a few more hours of work, a chest strap could easily be added.

I would argue that adding the picture of "Look, it can hold 25 pounds of rocks" implies it might be. And I know that the more tech oriented communities often don't appreciate ergonomics and have a tendency to just say "Oh cool, I can stick it to the man and save money!".

And this is one of those cases where there are some huge caveats.

Post reply on HN