Live data from Hacker News

In 63 days Trump will inherit mass surveillance from Obama

unplugthensa.org

11–20 of 26 posts

Re: In 63 days Trump will inherit mass surveillance from Obama

#12
It's a rather incoherent message. First, they state:

"Take action to dismantle the NSA"

which shouldn't be too difficult, just revoke the 1952 Presidential Order and defund them from the intelligence budget.

Then:

"The NSA has turned the Internet into a weapon, collecting everything it can. "

OK going steady so far, still on-message. All n-billion people on the Internet are in the dragnet and we're all nodding in agreement.

But then, when they enumerate their actual action-points:

"Delete the data stored on Americans, and demolish the physical infrastructure needed to collect this data. "

So it's not dismantling they actually want but blunting. Still want to keep the NSA to spy on those nasty non-persons abroad.

Look I don't have a problem with Americans calling for the NSA to stop spying on Americans, that's your internal problem. But please don't wrap it up in hyperbole about 'dismantling' the NSA if you don't actually mean that.

Re: In 63 days Trump will inherit mass surveillance from Obama

#13
post #6

Cracks me up this is presented like "Obama, come on, we know you're a good guy. Pleassssse". Give me a break... Barack loves extrajudicial powers. This is the problem with large, powerful governments. Sooner or later, the other guys will have the power. If you voted for Obama (ESPECIALLY twice) and you're worried about Trump having power over the NSA, I am laughing at you.

I don't think Obama will do anything, because I agree with you that he likes having this surveillance and his drone powers.

The problem is that Trump might be less responsible with the powers given to him.

Re: In 63 days Trump will inherit mass surveillance from Obama

#14

Why would Obama pardon Snowden, it is obvious he is in agreement on the whole "he is a traitor" thing. Also, why is Trump inheriting thing a motivating factor for anyone? "Oh God! Please give us back the situation where government overreach is back in the hands of career politicians!" How about you instead focus on petitioning to the new President who might actually be swayed into doing something about it if conserva…

Because the President-Elect has shown himself to be dangerously autocratic, almost comically (if it wasn't so tragic) unprepared for governance up to and including things known by 8th grade civics students, grudge-holding and vendetta-seeking, not a fan of freedom of the press, again almost comically (if it wasn't so tragic) sensitive to insults and slights, and shows no sense of even understanding, much less respecting, the institutions that we have built to rein in this sort of thing.

Like I get it, I was in the streets during Clinton's terms and during Bush's terms and I strongly opposed the expansion of the shadow surveillance state under Obama.

But pretending that handing it over to Trump is a normal handover to a Republican administration is whistling past the graveyard.

Re: In 63 days Trump will inherit mass surveillance from Obama

#16
post #13
post #6

Cracks me up this is presented like "Obama, come on, we know you're a good guy. Pleassssse". Give me a break... Barack loves extrajudicial powers. This is the problem with large, powerful governments. Sooner or later, the other guys will have the power. If you voted for Obama (ESPECIALLY twice) and you're worried about Trump having power over the NSA, I am laughing at you.

I don't think Obama will do anything, because I agree with you that he likes having this surveillance and his drone powers. The problem is that Trump might be less responsible with the powers given to him.

Or more responsible. We don't know anything yet.

Re: In 63 days Trump will inherit mass surveillance from Obama

#17
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think Obama will do anything, because I agree with you that he likes having this surveillance and his drone powers. The problem is that Trump might be less responsible with the powers given to him.

Or more responsible. We don't know anything yet.

Apparently, trump and his entourage are keeping an enemies list.

Re: In 63 days Trump will inherit mass surveillance from Obama

#18
post #13
post #6

Cracks me up this is presented like "Obama, come on, we know you're a good guy. Pleassssse". Give me a break... Barack loves extrajudicial powers. This is the problem with large, powerful governments. Sooner or later, the other guys will have the power. If you voted for Obama (ESPECIALLY twice) and you're worried about Trump having power over the NSA, I am laughing at you.

I don't think Obama will do anything, because I agree with you that he likes having this surveillance and his drone powers. The problem is that Trump might be less responsible with the powers given to him.

In my opinion the person who let this situation happen is less responsible from the two.

It's ironic to fear monger Trump who is not even in the office when the last, approved guy, created this mess and possibility in the first place.

Re: In 63 days Trump will inherit mass surveillance from Obama

#19
post #6

Cracks me up this is presented like "Obama, come on, we know you're a good guy. Pleassssse". Give me a break... Barack loves extrajudicial powers. This is the problem with large, powerful governments. Sooner or later, the other guys will have the power. If you voted for Obama (ESPECIALLY twice) and you're worried about Trump having power over the NSA, I am laughing at you.

You do realize the bush administration started this entire thing right? Get your facts right.

https://www.eff.org/nsa-spying/timeline

Re: In 63 days Trump will inherit mass surveillance from Obama

#20

Why would Obama pardon Snowden, it is obvious he is in agreement on the whole "he is a traitor" thing. Also, why is Trump inheriting thing a motivating factor for anyone? "Oh God! Please give us back the situation where government overreach is back in the hands of career politicians!" How about you instead focus on petitioning to the new President who might actually be swayed into doing something about it if conserva…

Because the President-Elect has shown himself to be dangerously autocratic, almost comically (if it wasn't so tragic) unprepared for governance up to and including things known by 8th grade civics students, grudge-holding and vendetta-seeking, not a fan of freedom of the press, again almost comically (if it wasn't so tragic) sensitive to insults and slights, and shows no sense of even understanding, much less respect…

Looks like that's what America wants in a leader as he was elected democratically.

Either enact the powers or don't. Assume anyone can become President.

Curious how Trump is "autocratic" and Obama is not. Was Obama not autocratic when he drone-killed US citizens without due process? I'm not even sure what the word means. Obviously the President is entrusted with some powers that are autocratic and some that are checked by the other branches.

Post reply on HN