Live data from Hacker News

A New Approach to Printing with Google Cloud Print

blog.chromium.org

11–20 of 28 posts

Re: A New Approach to Printing with Google Cloud Print

#11
post #8

Hmm, I could see this working in an Airport Express USB print kind of way; but too bad, Airport Express still requires the printing origin computer to have the printer drivers. If Apple (or anyone else for that matter) Express can support cloud print, that would be so much nicer.

dd-wrt maybe?

Thanks - a good find.

P.S: Love the profile blurb about being lost :-)

Re: A New Approach to Printing with Google Cloud Print

#15
post #13

I sure wish they'd propose something similar for scanners.

+1 to this. I wish there were a unified standard for networking scanners at all, actually. The majority of business scanners have arcane features to Email, FTP, or SMB-share the documents they scan. SMB is the usually only thing that invites practical use on a small business network, and the scanner's implementation of the protocol is almost always poor. I've encountered $5k copiers that could only copy to SMB shares on Windows XP, mysteriously failing for Server 2003 or Server 2008. I don't even want to think about trying it with Samba.

Networking a copier is no afternoon job, either. I've seen businesses where setting up their copier on Ethernet was such a bother that they just hook up the fax line instead and fax everything to their own eFax number whenever they need a PDF scan of a document.

My dream is that I could plug in an IP address/hostname to any scanner and I press Scan. The scanner contacts a daemon running on the host on a well-known port and protocol (if it's the first time, the host presents a dialog or something to confirm pairing) and then the file goes shoop over the network into a folder of my choosing.

Why does this not exist! In a networked world, scanners need to be more like faxes, except there is no fax equivalent on the TCP/IP level.

Re: A New Approach to Printing with Google Cloud Print

#16
post #13

I sure wish they'd propose something similar for scanners.

Exactly - combine the 2 and you might finally kill off the dreaded fax machine (which despite being more arcane than the floppy disk, stubbornly refuses to die)

My parents were trying to get a fax machine working over a VOIP line the other day - a 19.2K modem on a 20MBit DSL connection. Makes you cry a little when you think about it.

Re: A New Approach to Printing with Google Cloud Print

#18
I love the decoupling the driver from the PC idea, but I can't help but wonder where this is all heading.

Isn't Google just re-inventing the mainframe, where they own the mainframe and the rest of us are customers, er dumb terminals? In other words, is this an open standard where any two web-enabled devices can communicate? Or is it a Google-managed service ("we return the status of the print job back to you") where we're yet again investing in the success of Google? Seems like the latter to me. Perhaps I misread it.

Re: A New Approach to Printing with Google Cloud Print

#20
post #3

Google adds more data to their store. Will Google be retaining the documents to be printed in any way?

If you readed the linked article, it says it could work offline, the whole protocols are open source.

I'm not sure, but according to the patch, only client and proxy are open source. Cloud print service seems to be closed.

http://codereview.chromium.org/1566047/show

Post reply on HN