Live data from Hacker News

Upgrade your SSH keys

blog.g3rt.nl

11–20 of 159 posts

Re: Upgrade your SSH keys

#11
In Userify (ssh key manager that only distributes sudo roles and public keys -- you keep your private keys[1]) we're going to be disallowing DSS keys soon.

I like this post - it's good advice overall. Keys are easy to handle and in some ways more secure than certificate management (which relies on extra unnecessary infrastructure).

1. https://userify.com

Re: Upgrade your SSH keys

#12
post #6

If you have any RHEL machines, you might wanna keep an RSA (or ECDSA) key around. RHEL doesn't support Ed25519. I haven't checked, but I presume this also goes for CentOS, Scientific Linux, and other derivatives.

The article claims that RHEL7 supports Ed25519. Maybe RHEL6 and older do not.

Re: Upgrade your SSH keys

#13
post #5

https://www.reddit.com/r/netsec/comments/543ncp/upgrade_your...

I always find it interesting to see the disparity between comments here, and in /r/netsec on matters like this.

Here: Generally positive. Netsec: Most upvoted comments being complaints and assertions that it's bad advice. And for some reason, upvoted comments about NSA involvement in curves (which is exactly what 25519 is not).

Re: Upgrade your SSH keys

#17

Can someone explain to me why RSA 2048 is "recommended to change"? It's still the default for gpg keys and as far as I know is widely thought to be secure for at least few hundred years!

Without commenting at all on the practicalities of attacking it, it's reasonable to expect a higher level out of security from GPG than a standard TLS connection.

Your web server needs to key and manage many connections/sec, and any delays feed back into my web developers further arguing against the use of TLS. You can generally expect no one will be trying to break your current TLS sessions ten years from now. If that doesn't apply to your situation, you probably have bigger problems, such as the broken CA model.

Both of these scenarios may be different with GPG.

Re: Upgrade your SSH keys

#20

I disagree with the author. Before you go upgrading into ed25519, beware that the NSA/NIST is moving away from elliptical curve cryptography because it's very vulnerable to cracking with quantum attacks[0]. "So let me spell this out: despite the fact that quantum computers seem to be a long ways off and reasonable quantum-resistant replacement algorithms are nowhere to be seen, NSA decided to make this announcement p…

"battle tested" and "resistant to quantum computing" are complete opposites
Post reply on HN