Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Electric Nissan Leaf priced at $33,000 in U.S.

news.cnet.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–16 of 16 posts

Re: Electric Nissan Leaf priced at $33,000 in U.S.

#11

Post by grannyg00se »

SamAtt wrote: post #4
hotshothenry wrote: post #2

I think GM is going to really be sweating considering the Leaf will end up being $10K+ cheaper (after rebates and credits) and will be produced in higher quantities from a brand (Nissan) that doesn't have all that negative press associated with it that GM has had over the past 18 or so months

But the Volt has a backup in that it can run on Gas. I just don't see there being a large market for a purely electric car (at least not until there are widespread charging stations). Plus, and maybe it's just me but if a person is willing to buy a $33,000 car and a roughly $2,200 charging station (which you need since it takes 16hrs to charge over a normal 110V socket) I don't think money is their primary concern. E…

Is an 85mph limit significant?

On what U.S. roadway is it legal to travel any faster?

The fact that cars are starting to sell with built-in speed limits could lead to a mandatory limit for all cars. It's a bit of a paradox that manufacturers are permitted to build cars that go faster than the absolute maximum limit allowed on any roadway given the other areas of strict safety requirements in the industry.

When one considers the fact that car accidents lead to more deaths than homocide, it wouldn't be unreasonable to hear calls for all vehicles to be limited in top speed.

Re: Electric Nissan Leaf priced at $33,000 in U.S.

#12

Post by aidenn0 »

SamAtt wrote: post #10
stan_rogers wrote: post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The primary market for cars like this won't entail a full charge/discharge cycle in daily driving, so it is very practical to charge over common 110V. Don't think that a vehicle like this needs to suit every driver in every market in order to be successful -- there are plenty of places in the US (and in Canada) where a 40-50 mile driving day would be closer to the norm. And in northern areas, where industrial parking…

The question really isn't whether 100 miles would be fine most days it's what happens when you get stuck in traffic or you have to drive somewhere unexpected for an emergency. Without the ability to quickly stop at a gas station to refuel you're severely limiting yourself (and while I agree there will be more sockets in the future I think that's more a 5 year cycle than it is something that will happen right away)

Ah, but the nice thing about an electric car is that getting stuck in traffic doesn't hurt the mileage. In fact, I would not be surprised if it gets better mileage in stop-and-go than going 70. Especially since the 100 mile range they are advertising is based off of a test designed to simulate driving around downtown LA during rush hour (I'm assuming if it got better mileage on the freeway they would be advertising it's freeway range).

Re: Electric Nissan Leaf priced at $33,000 in U.S.

#13

Post by aarongough »

SamAtt wrote: post #10
stan_rogers wrote: post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The primary market for cars like this won't entail a full charge/discharge cycle in daily driving, so it is very practical to charge over common 110V. Don't think that a vehicle like this needs to suit every driver in every market in order to be successful -- there are plenty of places in the US (and in Canada) where a 40-50 mile driving day would be closer to the norm. And in northern areas, where industrial parking…

The question really isn't whether 100 miles would be fine most days it's what happens when you get stuck in traffic or you have to drive somewhere unexpected for an emergency. Without the ability to quickly stop at a gas station to refuel you're severely limiting yourself (and while I agree there will be more sockets in the future I think that's more a 5 year cycle than it is something that will happen right away)

One thing to remember is that with an electric vehicle there's no such thing as 'idling'. If you're stationary in a traffic jam the car isn't going to be using much juice (stereo, etc only) so that really shouldn't affect the range...

Re: Electric Nissan Leaf priced at $33,000 in U.S.

#14

Post by stan_rogers »

SamAtt wrote: post #10
stan_rogers wrote: post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The primary market for cars like this won't entail a full charge/discharge cycle in daily driving, so it is very practical to charge over common 110V. Don't think that a vehicle like this needs to suit every driver in every market in order to be successful -- there are plenty of places in the US (and in Canada) where a 40-50 mile driving day would be closer to the norm. And in northern areas, where industrial parking…

The question really isn't whether 100 miles would be fine most days it's what happens when you get stuck in traffic or you have to drive somewhere unexpected for an emergency. Without the ability to quickly stop at a gas station to refuel you're severely limiting yourself (and while I agree there will be more sockets in the future I think that's more a 5 year cycle than it is something that will happen right away)

Stuck in traffic isn't really an issue for an electric -- there's no idle cost (apart from environmentals and, of course, the head-splitting and door-rattling stereo). And how many times have you had an immediate need to drive 200 miles out of your way so quickly you couldn't rent?

[EDIT-ADDED] And the sockets are there already in a lot of places (think Michigan, Wisconsin, the Dakotas, most of Canada) it's just a matter of not turning off the switch at the end of February.

Re: Electric Nissan Leaf priced at $33,000 in U.S.

#15

Post by anamax »

stan_rogers wrote: post #7
SamAtt wrote: post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But the Volt has a backup in that it can run on Gas. I just don't see there being a large market for a purely electric car (at least not until there are widespread charging stations). Plus, and maybe it's just me but if a person is willing to buy a $33,000 car and a roughly $2,200 charging station (which you need since it takes 16hrs to charge over a normal 110V socket) I don't think money is their primary concern. E…

The primary market for cars like this won't entail a full charge/discharge cycle in daily driving, so it is very practical to charge over common 110V. Don't think that a vehicle like this needs to suit every driver in every market in order to be successful -- there are plenty of places in the US (and in Canada) where a 40-50 mile driving day would be closer to the norm. And in northern areas, where industrial parking…

> The primary market for cars like this won't entail a full charge/discharge cycle in daily driving, so it is very practical to charge over common 110V.

However, the leaf is not a very good "only car". It's at best a second car, and probably commute only.

$33k is a lot of gas, and it also takes insurance and registration.

Re: Electric Nissan Leaf priced at $33,000 in U.S.

#16

Post by frankus »

SamAtt wrote: post #4
hotshothenry wrote: post #2

I think GM is going to really be sweating considering the Leaf will end up being $10K+ cheaper (after rebates and credits) and will be produced in higher quantities from a brand (Nissan) that doesn't have all that negative press associated with it that GM has had over the past 18 or so months

But the Volt has a backup in that it can run on Gas. I just don't see there being a large market for a purely electric car (at least not until there are widespread charging stations). Plus, and maybe it's just me but if a person is willing to buy a $33,000 car and a roughly $2,200 charging station (which you need since it takes 16hrs to charge over a normal 110V socket) I don't think money is their primary concern. E…

The Leaf is more of the "microwave oven" of vehicles. It's vastly more convenient for most trips, but there are some things it just can't do.

It's been said that the best range extender for an electric car is a rental car. The net present value of two weeks' car rental per year, forever, is probably less than the $10,000 difference between the Volt and the Leaf.

The Volt will also require regular oil changes and other engine maintenance. About the only regular maintenance for a pure EV is putting air in the tires.

Post reply on HN