Demethylating agents, HDAC inhibitors, and their like can induce powerful effects on malignancies via (purportedly) primarily epigenetic mechanisms. I've seen patients with astronomically high leukemic counts return to normal blood counts on a few weeks of romidepsin, for instance. But when groups use epigenetics to study poverty related stress, risk of depression, etc, there is a very different political structure t…
Growing Pains for Field of Epigenetics
11–12 of 12 posts
Re: Growing Pains for Field of Epigenetics
#12Earlier quoted context omitted.
Your argument was cogent and reasonable until you used the term "SJW". It's a useless term, meaning different things to different people. The point you seem to be arguing could also be applied to the funding of string theory, and is one that I agree with. You won't find people like Lee Smolin saying that the disparity in research funding in these areas is due to "SJWs", rather they would point to the short term visio…
I agree, SJW is a pretty useless term. You're right. And I don't know much about string theory funding. I can only postulate. Regarding short term vision, medical research funding has consequences on huge outlays of public resources outside of the short-term vision of research funding you mentioned. Maybe string theory has very close parallels, but for example when it was recommended everyone get interval colonoscopi…
The scientific method dictates that something should be ideally explored until it's dis-proven. Unfortunately, the realities of limited R&D funding dictate that only the most popular, or public, research tracks tend to attract the funding. This has a carry-on effect in that new students in these fields are forced to go into the most popular fields of study, lest they not get funding.
WRT string theory, have a look at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Trouble_with_Physics . I'm not sure I 100% agree with Lee Smolin on this (he has a definite axe to grind), but the points he raises are equally applicable to any field of contentious, or cutting edge research.
Solving this is difficult. Obviously education of the general populous will help, but in lieu of this, perhaps we need mandated percentages of funding to each viable research track (a solution rife with problems of it's own).
In any case, this is a hard problem to solve, and will certainly cause problems in many areas of fundamental research in the future.