Live data from Hacker News

Trump’s brigade took over Reddit. Now Reddit is changing its rules to stop them

washingtonpost.com

11–20 of 41 posts

Re: Trump’s brigade took over Reddit. Now Reddit is changing its rules to stop them

#11
post #6

I feel like this article may be a bit unfair. It sounds like organically a community wields a large number of votes, and they aren't getting the same treatment as other communities on Reddit?

/r/the_donald is harassing moderators from other subreddits, the moderators take part in vote manipulation (for which their most active mod was recently banned). I actually wonder why the subreddit isn't shut down yet.

They said this before when overweight people didn't like to see posts from healthy-weight people.

Why don't they just state who the site is for in the TOS and people can decide up-front if its for them, instead of pretending to be organic and democratic? It's ok to lean right or left or fat, but state your mission.

Re: Trump’s brigade took over Reddit. Now Reddit is changing its rules to stop them

#12
One thing to note from /u/spez's announcement of the changes[1], which suggests the impact might not actually be that large:

>Interestingly enough, r/the_donald was already getting downvoted out of r/all yesterday morning before we made any changes. It seems the rest of the Reddit community had had enough. Ironically, r/EnoughTrumpSpam was hit harder than any other community when we rolled out the changes. That’s Reddit for you. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[1]: https://www.reddit.com/r/announcements/comments/4oedco/lets_...

Re: Trump’s brigade took over Reddit. Now Reddit is changing its rules to stop them

#14
As someone who visits Reddit purely for entertainment, I welcome the changes.

I can't stand Trump. But even if I was a supporter (or the subreddit in question was for a more amiable candidate), /r/all has been useless for the last couple of months. It's been swamped with hate speech and spam. I've stayed away from it altogether, which is a shame because it's a great way to find trending posts in subreddits I don't subscribe to.

An alternative would have been to allow users to block certain subreddits from their /r/all (making it /r/almost all, I guess). But this would have been difficult and confusing for new users and wouldn't help anonymous users at all.

I wonder if they lost a lot of traffic because of that subreddit.

Re: Trump’s brigade took over Reddit. Now Reddit is changing its rules to stop them

#17
post #13

I don't understand how r/sandersforpresident didn't also have the same effect on r/all during Bernie's rise...if there ever was a subreddit that had enthusiastically upvoting users, it was that one.

/u/spez addressed it a bit in his AMA. [1]

> It was a problem. A smaller problem, but still a problem. As I mentioned in my post, r/all has gone through waves of being overwhelmed by a specific community many, many times over the years. Sometimes it's healthy, sometimes it's funny, most of the time it's annoying, particularly during election years.

[1]: https://www.reddit.com/r/announcements/comments/4oedco/lets_...

Re: Trump’s brigade took over Reddit. Now Reddit is changing its rules to stop them

#20
post #12

One thing to note from /u/spez's announcement of the changes[1], which suggests the impact might not actually be that large: >Interestingly enough, r/the_donald was already getting downvoted out of r/all yesterday morning before we made any changes. It seems the rest of the Reddit community had had enough. Ironically, r/EnoughTrumpSpam was hit harder than any other community when we rolled out the changes. That’s Red…

Yeah, this is a pretty desperate nothing article
Post reply on HN