Live data from Hacker News

All European scientific publicly funded articles to be freely accessible by 2020

english.eu2016.nl

11–20 of 137 posts

Re: All European scientific publicly funded articles to be freely accessible by 2020

#11

I can see the evil people behind the TTIP getting in the way of this. Before this goes into effect, the US will execute order 66 and take all the articles down.

Would the US be doing this to protect the profits of Reed-Elsevier (based in London), Springer (Berlin) or the Nature Publishing Group (London)?

Re: All European scientific publicly funded articles to be freely accessible by 2020

#12
What does this mean in practice? Will the EU force the publishers to make them freely accessible? Will the EU only allow scientists to publish in open journals? Europe indirectly funds a lot of research. This will bleed into the workflow of scientists worldwide.

Re: All European scientific publicly funded articles to be freely accessible by 2020

#14

What does this mean in practice? Will the EU force the publishers to make them freely accessible? Will the EU only allow scientists to publish in open journals? Europe indirectly funds a lot of research. This will bleed into the workflow of scientists worldwide.

I bet, in practice, this will mean some researchers will avoid public funds as it will come with overhead they do not want (publishing rules). But for most this will be a big win.

Re: All European scientific publicly funded articles to be freely accessible by 2020

#15
post #11

I can see the evil people behind the TTIP getting in the way of this. Before this goes into effect, the US will execute order 66 and take all the articles down.

Would the US be doing this to protect the profits of Reed-Elsevier (based in London), Springer (Berlin) or the Nature Publishing Group (London)?

In the way that one hand washes the other?

Re: All European scientific publicly funded articles to be freely accessible by 2020

#16
Seems excellent but I'm afraid the EU will just pay a sweet bundle of money to the publishers for the privilege instead of making it a law. Either way I hope it also extends to the member states level eventually. The circus of avoiding conflict between EU funding and member state funding is often quite amusing so this will be interesting.

It feels almost ethically self evident that any research funded by citizens in any way should be made available to said citizens (and that's more or less 100% of research in Europe). Lets step in that direction.

Re: All European scientific publicly funded articles to be freely accessible by 2020

#17
post #2

"From 2020, all scientific publications on the results of publicly funded research must be freely available." is not "All European scientific articles". I've got at least three papers that wouldn't fall under that heading.

It's a matter of perspective. I'd argue most European research falls under this. If you work at a public university and are paid for it and do research during that time and publish it that should be covered. It would be pretty lame if only stuff that was explicitly funded in a research project would be covered.

Re: All European scientific publicly funded articles to be freely accessible by 2020

#18

What does this mean in practice? Will the EU force the publishers to make them freely accessible? Will the EU only allow scientists to publish in open journals? Europe indirectly funds a lot of research. This will bleed into the workflow of scientists worldwide.

Other option: publisher grants a single right to author or author's institution (but no one else) to make a copy available.

Re: All European scientific publicly funded articles to be freely accessible by 2020

#19
post #16

Seems excellent but I'm afraid the EU will just pay a sweet bundle of money to the publishers for the privilege instead of making it a law. Either way I hope it also extends to the member states level eventually. The circus of avoiding conflict between EU funding and member state funding is often quite amusing so this will be interesting. It feels almost ethically self evident that any research funded by citizens in…

What would the law say, and how would it prevent publishers from demanding money to publish now that their other sources of income have been cut off?

Re: All European scientific publicly funded articles to be freely accessible by 2020

#20

What does this mean in practice? Will the EU force the publishers to make them freely accessible? Will the EU only allow scientists to publish in open journals? Europe indirectly funds a lot of research. This will bleed into the workflow of scientists worldwide.

I bet, in practice, this will mean some researchers will avoid public funds as it will come with overhead they do not want (publishing rules). But for most this will be a big win.

Ahahahahaha.

First of all: Researchers won't avoid public funds, because there's never enough money.

Second of all: Most researchers HATE academic publishers and being forced to sign over their copyright to a paywall in exchange for nothing. But institutional evaluation criteria force you to do so.

EU banning non-open publications will force publishers to allow open access OR force universities to revise their criteria to accommodate the inability to publish publicly funded work in non-open journals.

I think all of my colleagues think this is a great thing. As do I. Elsevier can go blow a goat with their copyright assignment BS.

Post reply on HN