Live data from Hacker News

Ten lessons I wish I had learned before teaching differential equations (1997) [pdf]

math.toronto.edu

11–20 of 122 posts

Re: Ten lessons I wish I had learned before teaching differential equations (1997) [pdf]

#11
I'm proud to report that at my undergrad institution, Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology, they very successfully adhered to these rules (and I was taking ODEs there way back in 2005).

They had a custom textbook created for their 2-course ODE sequence that several of the faculty collaborated on. Though it did contain content on uniqueness theorems and some proofs, far and away the biggest two items hammered in were (a) linear equations with constant coefficients, and (b) Laplace transform methods.

They also offered (at the time) a 3rd, optional course called Boundary Value Problems that was focused on several physics-motivated BVPs like with Laplace's equation, heat equation, wave equation, Young's modulus, and others, and that course heavily used Fourier and Laplace methods.

We did have word problems, but they were almost exclusively "salt tank" problems. Literally, every word problem described a tank of water or pre-mixed brine solution, with some description of either more salt or more water being added or removed, either gradually or in discrete injections.

The fact that every problem was an infamous "salt-tank problem" essentially made its status as a word problem irrelevant. This seems like it wouldn't be that helpful but actually it was really nice. You got so used to the different pieces that comprised the modeling problem that when you went off and did something in other courses, like circuit systems or conservation systems in mechanical engineering, you knew how to translate the problem to 'salt tank' form, which really covered a huge range of practical problems.

As a math major, one fault I noticed of this method was that it did not make the connections to linear algebra very clear. It took me another few semesters afterward to catch up on that part, but I can understand how engineering majors cared less about that.

I don't know what Rose-Hulman does for this curriculum now, but it would be cool to somehow take a "snapshot" of their methods for it and compare it with other experiences like this OP.

Re: Ten lessons I wish I had learned before teaching differential equations (1997) [pdf]

#12
post #6

One lesson academics should learn: pdf-naming-skills.pdf. I've been collecting interesting scientific papers and publications since early 2000 (I've a collection of 10,000 or so) and I've not yet seen a single academic, not even a computer scientist, who understands how to name your documents right so that when I download them I could quickly find them. I've to rename every single pdf. It's infuriating. Someone shoul…

Everybody has a different system, and why should they standardize on yours?

What kind of a system is surname.pdf, New-Pub_New2new.pdf, USENIX_.PDF, and Paper.pdf.

I like to say: Show me how you organize your files, and I'll tell you how good of a computer user you are.

Re: Ten lessons I wish I had learned before teaching differential equations (1997) [pdf]

#13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Everybody has a different system, and why should they standardize on yours?

What kind of a system is surname.pdf, New-Pub_New2new.pdf, USENIX_.PDF, and Paper.pdf. I like to say: Show me how you organize your files, and I'll tell you how good of a computer user you are.

How good of a computer user do you have to be to sort by modified date? :P

Re: Ten lessons I wish I had learned before teaching differential equations (1997) [pdf]

#14
post #8
post #5

The last point may well be the best, "TEACH CONCEPTS, NOT TRICKS"

I am taking a refresher class in calculus II from a community college and am pained by the tricks being taught and feel that the students are being deprived of learning core concepts. I am taking the trouble to read up and not too focused on the solution techniques that the professor emphasizes. However this doesn't do too much for grades. I wish he focused on concepts and application.

But the bag of tricks is a feature of US undergrad education seemingly everywhere, except perhaps in pockets at the very highest level. The tricks permit the student to pass the test so they can go on to do something else. Whoever sits in a chemistry course isn't there for the chemistry, they are mostly there to go up to medical school or allied health science. Of course there are entrance exams.

We have stopped putting things into context, i.e. we do not provide an education any longer. The sideswipe remark in the original paper about Prof. Neanderthaler is also very real.

Re: Ten lessons I wish I had learned before teaching differential equations (1997) [pdf]

#15
post #6

One lesson academics should learn: pdf-naming-skills.pdf. I've been collecting interesting scientific papers and publications since early 2000 (I've a collection of 10,000 or so) and I've not yet seen a single academic, not even a computer scientist, who understands how to name your documents right so that when I download them I could quickly find them. I've to rename every single pdf. It's infuriating. Someone shoul…

The academic equivalent of the dreaded "resume.pdf".

Re: Ten lessons I wish I had learned before teaching differential equations (1997) [pdf]

#16
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What kind of a system is surname.pdf, New-Pub_New2new.pdf, USENIX_.PDF, and Paper.pdf. I like to say: Show me how you organize your files, and I'll tell you how good of a computer user you are.

How good of a computer user do you have to be to sort by modified date? :P

Lots of things can touch modification date.

It's ironic, because professors and instructors often ask their students to name their research papers, essays, and projects with a well-defined, searchable naming scheme.

Re: Ten lessons I wish I had learned before teaching differential equations (1997) [pdf]

#17
post #6

One lesson academics should learn: pdf-naming-skills.pdf. I've been collecting interesting scientific papers and publications since early 2000 (I've a collection of 10,000 or so) and I've not yet seen a single academic, not even a computer scientist, who understands how to name your documents right so that when I download them I could quickly find them. I've to rename every single pdf. It's infuriating. Someone shoul…

What's wrong with any of the pieces of reference management software out there? I use Endnote, others may have different preferences. Reference management and document retrieval is a problem that popped up together with the first library, and library classification has evolved alongside. I wouldn't say it's a solved problem, but it's a known problem with known attempts at solution. Attempting to roll your own is so reminiscent of OpenSSL, and they keep getting into trouble with their habit of inventing the wheel.

Re: Ten lessons I wish I had learned before teaching differential equations (1997) [pdf]

#18
I once told a math teacher at a Big Ten university, that I thought their undergrad math instruction for engineers was weak. As an example, I said that I didn't think students learned any engineering applications of differential equations. He looked at me with a straight face and said: "There are no engineering applications of differential equations."

Re: Ten lessons I wish I had learned before teaching differential equations (1997) [pdf]

#19
post #6

One lesson academics should learn: pdf-naming-skills.pdf. I've been collecting interesting scientific papers and publications since early 2000 (I've a collection of 10,000 or so) and I've not yet seen a single academic, not even a computer scientist, who understands how to name your documents right so that when I download them I could quickly find them. I've to rename every single pdf. It's infuriating. Someone shoul…

Even worse: instead of having a discussion on college mathematics pedagogy and differential equations, you decided this was the most relevant thing to discuss, made even more totally irrelevant by the fact that 1) it's a futile suggestion, 2) the original author is dead, and 3) you haven't heard of full-text search or file renaming.

Re: Ten lessons I wish I had learned before teaching differential equations (1997) [pdf]

#20

I once told a math teacher at a Big Ten university, that I thought their undergrad math instruction for engineers was weak. As an example, I said that I didn't think students learned any engineering applications of differential equations. He looked at me with a straight face and said: "There are no engineering applications of differential equations."

I took the differential equation course over a summer, which means an entire semester was condensed into four weeks. I passed the class but I couldn't tell you a single application for differential equations at the time.

Don't know if the professor could've done anything better or if they had no choice but to plow through it because of the time constraints.

Post reply on HN