Live data from Hacker News

The Joys and Challenges of Hiring Developer Bootcamp Grads

sfviapgh.com

11–20 of 28 posts

Re: The Joys and Challenges of Hiring Developer Bootcamp Grads

#11
On one hand I am glad that graduates are getting education and opportunities without subjecting themselves to mainstream educational institutions.

On the other hand, it does concern me that this is one step closer in the race to the bottom for developers.

It won't be long before being a developer is just another poorly paying job.

Re: The Joys and Challenges of Hiring Developer Bootcamp Grads

#12
As the guy monitoring the end of a dev hiring email let me broach another challenge.

I have no way to wade through the high volume of identical resumes coming out of these programs. Every Hack Reactor grad has the exact same thing as every other grad. Its very difficult to weed out anyone in this scenario without setting up a call with every grad that applies which isn't a scalable model for hiring junior engineers. The single biggest reason I've not given enough BG's a shot is the level of effort needed of finding a good one or one who's the right fit.

Note some programs have started setting up mechanisms to interact with a bunch of grads in a group (we've done this) and this has been a decent way of doing this.

Re: The Joys and Challenges of Hiring Developer Bootcamp Grads

#13

I've worked with two bootstrap grads, the ones that come from the 8-week program. One of them I hired directly onto my team. It's been a great experience! The developer I hired is moving on because he found a better paying position (as a coder). I view this as a success and I'm happy for him. It took him 8 months to get to this point and I'm sad to see him go. Things I learned: - They come in excited but they have so…

I just want to say you also need to consider business fit. If your business can't afford to train a bootstrap grad properly(whether is time deadlines or money), don't hire them. I've seen two great guys just completely burnout because not only was our app complex, they just weren't familiar enough with some of fundamentals you get in a cs undergrad for our timelines. They tried their hardest though.

Re: The Joys and Challenges of Hiring Developer Bootcamp Grads

#14
Tried the boot camp route, went to demo day and chose our 6 favorite, out of those 6 interviews we hired 3, one turned out to be pretty good but honestly needed so much hand holding it wasn't worth it in the long run. Plus all of the boot camps have been putting 6 figure dreams in their head which is truly unjustifiable for their experience. If I want entry level, I'll go with college grads, just way less headache.

Re: The Joys and Challenges of Hiring Developer Bootcamp Grads

#15

On one hand I am glad that graduates are getting education and opportunities without subjecting themselves to mainstream educational institutions. On the other hand, it does concern me that this is one step closer in the race to the bottom for developers. It won't be long before being a developer is just another poorly paying job.

This sort of thing has happened before, with the "fog a mirror" interviews of 1999 and all the offshoring that happened a few years later. In the first case people all thought there was plenty of room in the "new economy" but our jobs would all be dumbed down permanently, in the latter there was a lot of doom and gloom about how software development was no sort of future for first-world children.

But in both cases, the results were brutal to the companies that jumped in thoughtlessly. I've no doubt the same is true here again. Over the long term I expect we'll see some big changes in career education but I don't think established professionals are going to be overrun with high school dropouts anytime soon.

Re: The Joys and Challenges of Hiring Developer Bootcamp Grads

#16

On one hand I am glad that graduates are getting education and opportunities without subjecting themselves to mainstream educational institutions. On the other hand, it does concern me that this is one step closer in the race to the bottom for developers. It won't be long before being a developer is just another poorly paying job.

That kind of attitude can only mean one thing: you doubt your own skills and the usefulness of what you do.

Re: The Joys and Challenges of Hiring Developer Bootcamp Grads

#17

Let's not paint this subject with a broad brush. Depends on the choice and depth of curriculum, length of time, the student and the instructor. Having said that no bootcamp or hacker school can give you 20 years of experience writing and maintaining software. That's really the disavdantage. But natural talent in rare individuals can replace that with intuition, although I'm not sure how people like that do over the l…

Having said that no bootcamp or hacker school can give you 20 years of experience writing and maintaining software.

Neither does a Masters from M.I.T. or Stanford. I only say this because I'm not exactly sure what your point is. What I hear you saying is, "it takes about two decades to code like you've been doing it for 20 years."

Re: The Joys and Challenges of Hiring Developer Bootcamp Grads

#19
post #16

On one hand I am glad that graduates are getting education and opportunities without subjecting themselves to mainstream educational institutions. On the other hand, it does concern me that this is one step closer in the race to the bottom for developers. It won't be long before being a developer is just another poorly paying job.

That kind of attitude can only mean one thing: you doubt your own skills and the usefulness of what you do.

Please read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html ... this is awfully close to a personal attack.

Re: The Joys and Challenges of Hiring Developer Bootcamp Grads

#20

"Bootcamp Grads" is a pretty broad phrase; we might want to start using more precise language. An grad from an 8-week bootcamp will have a different skill set than someone who spent 18, 48, 72 weeks in a bootcamp program. Also, Thoughtbot has a somewhat good guide to running an apprenticeship: https://github.com/thoughtbot/apprenticeship It could be adapted without much work to hiring bootcamp grads.

Hmmm.... If you're doing 48 or 72(!) weeks, I wouldn't call it a bootcamp so much as an unaccredited master's program...
Post reply on HN