Live data from Hacker News

India's Great Parcel Race

graphics.wsj.com

11–20 of 20 posts

Re: India's Great Parcel Race

#11
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

... because India won't take care of them?

There is little justice in India if you do no have some kind of influence. So if you are poor = little real justice = yes, India currently doesnt care very well for their poor.

True, and not necessarily a situation unique to India.

Re: India's Great Parcel Race

#13
post #9
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

India is a very divided country. So, if you are catering to top 10% of the population you are already in the ball-park of 100 million people, that pretty much beats out every Western country except USA. The number in middle class is about 400million, that is the number to focus at least for immediate future. The rest of 800 million, well, God Bless them!

... because India won't take care of them?

Correct. It is up to the Gods.

Re: India's Great Parcel Race

#14

e-commerce changed the way people buy things here in remote places in India. They could buy things that was not even in their dreams few years back. E-commerce advertisements cover most front pages of newspapers now. More startups are coming up in logistics space. Amazon, Alibaba etc has started investing here seeing the market potential. Logistics here is a big problem. Since local sellers are feeling the heat, they…

How will this impact people? Many of those local sellers already are very poor. I wouldn't be surprised to find out that families are starving as a consequence. For example, thousands of farmers in India are committing suicide per year, apparently due to economic conditions.

Re: India's Great Parcel Race

#15

e-commerce changed the way people buy things here in remote places in India. They could buy things that was not even in their dreams few years back. E-commerce advertisements cover most front pages of newspapers now. More startups are coming up in logistics space. Amazon, Alibaba etc has started investing here seeing the market potential. Logistics here is a big problem. Since local sellers are feeling the heat, they…

How will this impact people? Many of those local sellers already are very poor. I wouldn't be surprised to find out that families are starving as a consequence. For example, thousands of farmers in India are committing suicide per year, apparently due to economic conditions.

The suicide by drinking pesticides were happening for a long time, especially since mid-90s. The rate of increase has more to do with public policy , price controls and sub-par pesticides, fertilizers and seeds. The cock-tail of GATT, WTO restriction on farmer subsidies coupled with price controls and adulterated products, has created the farmer suicide hell.

ECommerce and logistics have nothing to do with it.

Re: India's Great Parcel Race

#16
post #9
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

India is a very divided country. So, if you are catering to top 10% of the population you are already in the ball-park of 100 million people, that pretty much beats out every Western country except USA. The number in middle class is about 400million, that is the number to focus at least for immediate future. The rest of 800 million, well, God Bless them!

... because India won't take care of them?

No, they'll be sending them your way to Sweden ;-)

Re: India's Great Parcel Race

#17
post #6
post #4

"India's per capita income (nominal) was $ 1570 in 2013." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_in_India So like 30-50 times less than a "western" country. :/

India is a very divided country. So, if you are catering to top 10% of the population you are already in the ball-park of 100 million people, that pretty much beats out every Western country except USA. The number in middle class is about 400million, that is the number to focus at least for immediate future. The rest of 800 million, well, God Bless them!

It's not hard to get them out of poverty. See this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PVjZjPbHrFE

Re: India's Great Parcel Race

#19
post #4

"India's per capita income (nominal) was $ 1570 in 2013." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_in_India So like 30-50 times less than a "western" country. :/

That's nominal; it's much higher by PPP. (Still much lower than the global West and North, of course.)
Post reply on HN