Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Founder visa bill proposed

readwriteweb.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–20 of 28 posts

Re: Founder visa bill proposed

#11

Post by jacquesm »

aristus wrote: post #10
jacquesm wrote: post #9

The funny thing is that not that many people that would be able to afford this would actually do it. The USA is a nice country but there are many parameters that go in to the decision of choosing a place to live and it scores low on plenty of those. The US is the destination country of choice for people without money. Those with money are just as likely to go elsewhere.

I have to disagree, at least anecdotally. I know several people, whom I'm pretty sure don't have to work if they don't want to. Yet they moved to the US specifically in order to start companies. And even they, rich, educated folk from "good" countries have had ridiculous amounts of trouble getting visas and work permission.

Anecdotally, I know at least several Americans that have moved to Europe, at least one pretty affluent.

But anecdotes are nice, numbers are better. For every wealthy person that would like to get 'in' to the US there must be 50,000 poor ones.

The difference is that for them nobody is going out of their way to create special visa to allow them entrance.

Re: Founder visa bill proposed

#12

Post by dghughes »

In my province there was a similar program, Provincial Nominee Program or PNP, an immigrant would invest $200,000 in a local business plus give a $25,000 deposit to the provincial government and the immigrant investor's citizenship request would be fast-tracked.

After living here for a year they were supposed to get the deposit back, but they didn't.

Even worse is the majority of the people who benefited were the same politicians who set up the program.

Now it's a huge scandal and the police are involved, large amounts of money plus politicians and there's a scandal, imagine that!

Re: Founder visa bill proposed

#13

Post by ajaimk »

Timeline seems highly appropriate for me since I graduate from college in 2 years (since I am on a student visa). Maybe I will be able to stay in the US and work on my startup as I want to (during the best years of my life) than sell my soul for a corporate job.

Re: Founder visa bill proposed

#15

Post by cwan »

jacquesm wrote: post #9

The funny thing is that not that many people that would be able to afford this would actually do it. The USA is a nice country but there are many parameters that go in to the decision of choosing a place to live and it scores low on plenty of those. The US is the destination country of choice for people without money. Those with money are just as likely to go elsewhere.

One thing the stats don't show, and I'm quite curious about, are those who are wealthy but seek greater (or even continue to seek) opportunities. The bulk of taxes don't tax wealth - they tax income (and gains on wealth like capital gains, interest and dividends get treated differently depending on where you go). Perversely, the rich have the luxury then to be subsidized for certain parameters because they don't need to pay for what they see as the benefits of living in that given place.

For this reason, you can get some remarkable statements like the year that Warren Buffett said something to the effect that there is something wrong with a system when his secretary gets taxed as a percent more than he does. Of course, we later learned this was somewhat disingenuous given most of his income wasn't personal income at all but dividends (http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/money/tax/article1996735.ec...).

This being said, how is your comment relevant to the startup visa? The idea as I understand it would be to attract those without money but who need it from VC's - and as you say, the US is often the destination of choice for those like that. The point being to attract great entrepreneurs from countries that don't welcome them - at least a number of countries being a case in point: http://www.foreignpolicy.com/story/cms.php?story_id=4095&#38... - "In one 2005 poll, just 36 percent of French citizens said they supported the free-enterprise system, the only one of 22 countries polled that showed minority support for this cornerstone of global commerce. In Germany, meanwhile, support for socialist ideals is running at all-time highs—47 percent in 2007 versus 36 percent in 1991."

Re: Founder visa bill proposed

#16

Post by mivok »

ajaimk wrote: post #14

What if the company fails in 6 months? Do note that the visa is one for "Permanent" residence.

It's possible that it will end up being a 'conditional permanent residence' that you have to renew after 2 years (the condition being that you still have the company). This is what happens for green cards that are granted on the basis of a new marriage.

Re: Founder visa bill proposed

#17

Post by ajaimk »

mivok wrote: post #16
ajaimk wrote: post #14

What if the company fails in 6 months? Do note that the visa is one for "Permanent" residence.

It's possible that it will end up being a 'conditional permanent residence' that you have to renew after 2 years (the condition being that you still have the company). This is what happens for green cards that are granted on the basis of a new marriage.

That would probably work. I just hope we don't end up with another SARBOX where the requirements outweigh the benefits

Re: Founder visa bill proposed

#18

Post by ajaimk »

mechanical_fish wrote: post #8
leecho0 wrote: post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wealthy foreigners already do buy their way into the States through the EB-5 visa. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EB-5_visa The startup visa seeks to change the EB-5 visa to include people who aren't wealthy, but would also create jobs in the US by starting viable companies.

This is an interesting link. I always wondered how much money I would need to buy my way into permanent residency in any country in the world. (I am assuming that the USA is among the most difficult -- those with expertise, please correct me if I'm wrong.) It's one of those useful benchmarks for how rich "rich" is. The price is high, but not astoundingly high, if I'm reading this right. You need $500k in capital that…

Then it might interest you that Panama requires only proof that you made $500/month to get a retirement visa

Re: Founder visa bill proposed

#19

Post by ajaimk »

jacquesm wrote: post #9

The funny thing is that not that many people that would be able to afford this would actually do it. The USA is a nice country but there are many parameters that go in to the decision of choosing a place to live and it scores low on plenty of those. The US is the destination country of choice for people without money. Those with money are just as likely to go elsewhere.

I see this as a good opportunity to retain startup oriented students attending US colleges.

Re: Founder visa bill proposed

#20

Post by anamax »

JimmyL wrote: post #5
leelin wrote: post #2

Personally, I think the more wealth and brains we have in the country the better, but $100K seems cheap enough to invite lots of shady cases. I could start the "Visa Arbitrage Angel Fund" that only makes $100K investments into startups with $20K+ in the bank, then require the startup buy me out one week after closing for $120K (or make monthly payments of $10K for a year, or some other wacky clause that makes my inve…

You probably could - and one could make the argument that someone that industrious is exactly the kind of person you'd want. However, the visa status is contingent on the company following through with its business plan to create X job and/or take in $1M of revenue. If the company isn't doing that (or if "the investment in the commercial enterprise was intended solely as a means of evading the immigration laws of the…

> the visa gets pulled and the deportation process begins.

> One can also imagine that INS would keep a very tight leash on the program in its first few years to make sure this isn't happening.

Experience with student and vacation visas suggests otherwise.

Post reply on HN