Live data from Hacker News

Ask: Do you still find any benefits in using handwriting?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 61 posts

Re: Ask: Do you still find any benefits in using handwriting?

#11
Hell yes. Except when writing long documents keyboard it is, of course.

However, I find retrieval and sketching, not to speak of mathematical formulas and diagramming, much easier from a physical notebook.

I've not yet found a digital medium superior to that of a physical notebook for doing 'notebooklike' things.

Re: Ask: Do you still find any benefits in using handwriting?

#12
post #7

We obviously type more than we write now, but I've always found the implicit suggestion of abandoning writing, or engaging in the hypothetical of having to pick only one, a bit of a pointless discussion. While it's not an exact analogy, I would say it's like walking and swimming. Both can get you somewhere, but just because we do one a lot more than the other doesn't mean we don't need both.

That's true for our generation, but future generations might lose the hability to do both as we move to a 100% digital era.

Re: Ask: Do you still find any benefits in using handwriting?

#13
The constant need for combining text with small sketches makes pen and paper a useful tool. Less to do with handwriting, more with the flexibility pen and paper offers.

Write my diary by hand. Makes it pretty much unhackable and it's a good way to start the day. Habit I guess.

Re: Ask: Do you still find any benefits in using handwriting?

#14
when I write on paper I can instantaneously use scale, spacing, font size, font style, text orientation, illustration, flow charts and more to impart a lot more information into a space than I can do just bashing out on a keyboard, I love computers, I love paper too, I think a union is the best of both worlds but a portable paper equivalent is still a way off.

Re: Ask: Do you still find any benefits in using handwriting?

#15
I still write a variety of things. I've found it improves my ability to recall the things I write

> Some say that because we write slower than we type, it allows for deeper thinking as opposed to faster thinking, which could be beneficial. Since writing takes longer, I tend to mull over what I'm trying to communicate and condense it. This is likely why I remember it better. However ....

> because it's harder to edit one is more careful while writing Absolutely not! Given a half pages written text I would likely have no less than a dozen clear markups where I revised or edited a thought.

I certainly don't want to write everything, or produce professional quality hand-written text, but I find benefit in actually writing things down

Re: Ask: Do you still find any benefits in using handwriting?

#16
post #11

Hell yes. Except when writing long documents keyboard it is, of course. However, I find retrieval and sketching, not to speak of mathematical formulas and diagramming, much easier from a physical notebook. I've not yet found a digital medium superior to that of a physical notebook for doing 'notebooklike' things.

In my opinion the closest thing is the Microsoft surface with OneNote. I thought I would use it lots. But sketch down on pen and paper and photograph it with smartphone works just as well.

Re: Ask: Do you still find any benefits in using handwriting?

#17
post #7

We obviously type more than we write now, but I've always found the implicit suggestion of abandoning writing, or engaging in the hypothetical of having to pick only one, a bit of a pointless discussion. While it's not an exact analogy, I would say it's like walking and swimming. Both can get you somewhere, but just because we do one a lot more than the other doesn't mean we don't need both.

That's true for our generation, but future generations might lose the hability to do both as we move to a 100% digital era.

That's kind of the reasoning I'm rejecting. In the year 1915, Americans could on average tie 100 knots (can't cite the source, but yes it was something I once read), and I'm sure many more were a bit more seafaring and horse riding. As we developed cars and planes and clips, all those skills have receded. They aren't gone, we can all tie our shoes and swim in a pool, but these are physical actions, I doubt we'll ever lose them. And yes, kids are dumb, but eventually they become adults who understand that writing has a place in their lives.

Re: Ask: Do you still find any benefits in using handwriting?

#18
Whenever I see someone's good handwriting, I carry an instant good impression for the person. Throughout my school days, me and my friends used to compete how we can control our handwriting - trying out many wild ways - slants, curls, curves, et al ad we loved it. It was never academic but felt really good and satisfying. We've also seen other schools whose students had really good handwriting. Love them, appreciated them and we would secretly try to be better than them.

I guess that paid off in the long run. No many people really give much importance to handwriting, more so these days but I feel nice writing and still try to write as much as I can (always have few notebooks with me at all times + a bunch of pens and pencils). Besides the appreciations I usually get, I like the fact that people admire that I dedicate to writing too besides my involvement with technology and that I stayed in touch with the art of writing.

I'm trying to inculcate a similar habit with my kid - write beautiful, and master the intricacies of handwriting - it is lovely, sweet, sophisticated, classical and clean.

:-)

Re: Ask: Do you still find any benefits in using handwriting?

#19
All through high school and most of college, I took notes on my laptop. Once I got into grad school, I gave that up and started taking notes in a notebook by hand; I was the only person in the CS department who took notes by hand, but it helped me to recall information, made it easier to review my notes later, and gave me the freedom to draw whatever diagrams I needed.

Also, writing notes on post-it notes or on a whiteboard are basically what makes completing any project that takes longer than a day possible for me.

Re: Ask: Do you still find any benefits in using handwriting?

#20
post #11

Hell yes. Except when writing long documents keyboard it is, of course. However, I find retrieval and sketching, not to speak of mathematical formulas and diagramming, much easier from a physical notebook. I've not yet found a digital medium superior to that of a physical notebook for doing 'notebooklike' things.

I think OneNote does a great job of replacing my notepad. I use it to take notes on everything I learn and might need for later. Great for documenting processes and throwing lots of screenshots into. Way easier to find things later then some random page in my notebook.

I also use it for a daily log of my tasks and what I need to accomplish. Used to use a notebook for both these things, but I find it easier/faster to jump into onenote and back into what i am working on then

Post reply on HN