Live data from Hacker News

Rethinking the Origins of the Lock

schuylertowne.com

1–10 of 11 posts

Re: Rethinking the Origins of the Lock

#2
Something I've wondered: is the lock the first machine to do a discrete, conditional action? That'd make it a kind of ancestor to digital computers, before various automata and then Jacquard and Babbage.

Feedback control goes back to the first millennium BC, too, but that seems more like analog computing.

Re: Rethinking the Origins of the Lock

#4

Something I've wondered: is the lock the first machine to do a discrete, conditional action? That'd make it a kind of ancestor to digital computers, before various automata and then Jacquard and Babbage. Feedback control goes back to the first millennium BC, too, but that seems more like analog computing.

> is the lock the first machine to do a discrete, conditional action?

Interesting question.

I would guess that the answer is "no". Animal traps based on some kind of triggered action probably predated the keyed lock.

Re: Rethinking the Origins of the Lock

#5

Something I've wondered: is the lock the first machine to do a discrete, conditional action? That'd make it a kind of ancestor to digital computers, before various automata and then Jacquard and Babbage. Feedback control goes back to the first millennium BC, too, but that seems more like analog computing.

> is the lock the first machine to do a discrete, conditional action? Interesting question. I would guess that the answer is "no". Animal traps based on some kind of triggered action probably predated the keyed lock.

Good point! I feel embarrassed. Thanks.

(Maybe the lock could still get credit for the logical AND?)

Re: Rethinking the Origins of the Lock

#7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> is the lock the first machine to do a discrete, conditional action? Interesting question. I would guess that the answer is "no". Animal traps based on some kind of triggered action probably predated the keyed lock.

Good point! I feel embarrassed. Thanks. (Maybe the lock could still get credit for the logical AND?)

Never feel embarrassed for asking a great question!

Re: Rethinking the Origins of the Lock

#10

Something I've wondered: is the lock the first machine to do a discrete, conditional action? That'd make it a kind of ancestor to digital computers, before various automata and then Jacquard and Babbage. Feedback control goes back to the first millennium BC, too, but that seems more like analog computing.

That might be the screw (hold if push, moved if twisted). Though I suppose a screw could be seen as a very basic kind of lock.
Post reply on HN