Live data from Hacker News

Ageing: The girls who never grow older

bbc.com

1–10 of 44 posts

Re: Ageing: The girls who never grow older

#2
Summary:

There are no conclusions or new research in this article.

Talks about some theories of the scientist interviewed about what aging is (Spoiler: He doesn't know and all current theories have flaws), wastes some time on human interest fluff, gives an interesting picture of girls with Syndrome X (that prevents them from developing, in a way that might be a lack of aging - if you've already heard about it there is nothing new here, if not this is a reasonable introduction), but has no conclusions or new information.

They are doing genetic testing of the girls involved, results are not in yet, this article should have waited for the results.

Re: Ageing: The girls who never grow older

#3
Amazingly this can't be accessed from the UK, a bizarre consequence of the license fee:

We're sorry but this site is not accessible from the UK as it is part of our international service and is not funded by the licence fee. It is run commercially by BBC Worldwide, a wholly-owned subsidiary of the BBC, the profits made from it go back to BBC programme-makers to help fund great new BBC programmes. You can find out more about BBC Worldwide and its digital activities at www.bbcworldwide.com.

Re: Ageing: The girls who never grow older

#4

Amazingly this can't be accessed from the UK, a bizarre consequence of the license fee: We're sorry but this site is not accessible from the UK as it is part of our international service and is not funded by the licence fee. It is run commercially by BBC Worldwide, a wholly-owned subsidiary of the BBC, the profits made from it go back to BBC programme-makers to help fund great new BBC programmes. You can find out mor…

BBC re-posted the article from this source: http://mosaicscience.com/story/arrested-development

Re: Ageing: The girls who never grow older

#6
The takeaway of this story for me, after reading this, is not the scientific implications, but I come away with tremendous sympathy and respect for the parents.

Having just become a father a few weeks ago, I'm beyond grateful that our son so far appears to be a healthy boy and when I read about parents having to deal with adverse health events of their children, I can't think of anything tougher to go through than that. I don't know if I would have the strength or resilience to do what these parents did (raise these girls, who never develop beyond infancy), nor do I know whether it's the "right thing to do" (or if there even is such a distinction under the circumstances), but I respect the hell out of them.

Re: Ageing: The girls who never grow older

#7
post #2

Summary: There are no conclusions or new research in this article. Talks about some theories of the scientist interviewed about what aging is (Spoiler: He doesn't know and all current theories have flaws), wastes some time on human interest fluff, gives an interesting picture of girls with Syndrome X (that prevents them from developing, in a way that might be a lack of aging - if you've already heard about it there i…

I actually thought this article did a pretty good job explaining why we age. As pointed out, our bodies fall apart because they are the product of an evolutionary process.

Our genetic code is like a computer program that runs into a bunch of fatal errors after it has been left running for too long. These fatal errors do not matter to our genes provided enough time has elapsed since our birth for our DNA to pass on several copies of itself. There is simply an absence of selective pressure for us to live past a certain reproductive age.

(If I wrote in laymen's terms it is because I am a laymen on the issue, but a well informed one at that.)

Re: Ageing: The girls who never grow older

#8
This is a new article on a condition that's been written about already.

These are children who fail to reach maturity normally.

All of this was evidence of what Walker dubbed “developmental disorganisation”. Brooke’s body seemed to be developing not as a coordinated unit, he wrote, but rather as a collection of individual, out-of-sync parts. “She is not simply ‘frozen in time’,” Walker wrote. “Her development is continuing, albeit in a disorganised fashion.”

The first this subject came up here, someone pointed out this has nothing really to do with the aging that anyone would want to stop. It might help understand the process of development and maturation but it clearly won't help us directly stop aging.

And "never grow older" seems like a rather poor and even cruel way to describe a unfortunate syndrome.

Re: Ageing: The girls who never grow older

#10
post #2

Summary: There are no conclusions or new research in this article. Talks about some theories of the scientist interviewed about what aging is (Spoiler: He doesn't know and all current theories have flaws), wastes some time on human interest fluff, gives an interesting picture of girls with Syndrome X (that prevents them from developing, in a way that might be a lack of aging - if you've already heard about it there i…

This sort of comment is highly appreciated. Thanks.
Post reply on HN