Live data from Hacker News

Tesla founder Elon Musk may be headed for a "stunning fall"

bloombergview.com

1–10 of 33 posts

Re: Tesla founder Elon Musk may be headed for a "stunning fall"

#3
Heard the same arguments when Musk tried to get into rockets. He has no experience making rockets.

Then there was the naysaying when Apple was first getting into phones. What does Apple know about phones? How can they possibly compete with the likes of Nokia?

Often industries are disrupted by newcomers who aren't constrained by the thinking of the existing players. Yes, Musk can't violate the laws of physics or economics. But the cost structures of existing players aren't always dictated by the fundamentals, but also by their own organizational baggage and structure. Hence, SpaceX can compete effectively with DoD defense contractors hooked on hugely inefficient government contracts. Is it that Boeing or Lockheed can't things as cheaply, or that SpaceX quality has to suffer? Maybe the way the government dictates things get funded and manufactured leads to inefficiencies, like spreading things around congressional districts.

Likewise, for other car companies, the Big Three in particular, they are somewhat constrained by their existing investments, existing unions, and just plain old conservativism and aversion to risk taking.

So maybe Musk will fail utterly. No pain, no gain I say. He also has a chance of succeeding spectacularly.

Re: Tesla founder Elon Musk may be headed for a "stunning fall"

#6

Heard the same arguments when Musk tried to get into rockets. He has no experience making rockets. Then there was the naysaying when Apple was first getting into phones. What does Apple know about phones? How can they possibly compete with the likes of Nokia? Often industries are disrupted by newcomers who aren't constrained by the thinking of the existing players. Yes, Musk can't violate the laws of physics or econo…

Perfectly stated

Re: Tesla founder Elon Musk may be headed for a "stunning fall"

#7
He also fails to mention when he's bashing the quality of the Tesla that it was ranked by consumer reports as the best car of 2014. As well as motor trend's car of the year in 2013. The stock might be overpriced, but the Tesla is the only car that has non car enthusiasts talking. My Father in law and my mother, two out of touch folks both wanna get a Tesla and can't stop talking about them. There is serious consumer demand waiting in the wings for a cheaper Tesla.

Re: Tesla founder Elon Musk may be headed for a "stunning fall"

#8
Just some more media trolling, nothing to see here, folks.

Even if he is were for a "stunning fail", let him fail gloriously and fantastically. It only means he'll be that much better at this next time around.

I'm completely confident in his ability to fail in order to succeed.

IMHO, Musk is a rare entrepreneur because it's obvious he considers all lessons learned, isn't afraid to learn new ones, and carries that wisdom forward into each decision he makes.

Re: Tesla founder Elon Musk may be headed for a "stunning fall"

#10
post #2

Interesting the article makes fun of Musk because of the hyperloop idea, but fails to look at SpaceX, which, to me, legitimizes Musk's grand visions. Who would have thought 20 years ago a private company would be reloading the ISS instead of NASA?

At an order of magnitude less cost
Post reply on HN