Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Java Debugger – The Definitive List of Tools

takipiblog.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

1–10 of 12 posts

Re: Java Debugger – The Definitive List of Tools

#3

Post by beersigns »

heapster wrote: post #2

> Main tools: In this category two tools lead the pack today - Eclipse and NetBeans. NetBeans? Seriously?! Where's IntelliJ IDEA? Does IntelliJ have a different way of debugging? I believe it's much more popular than NetBeans

I've always considered IntelliJ as the Cadillac of Java IDEs. Eclipse(or plug-in modded Eclipse) seems to be the most common in places I've worked. NetBeans seems to be less popular than either.

Re: Java Debugger – The Definitive List of Tools

#4

Post by peeters »

heapster wrote: post #2

> Main tools: In this category two tools lead the pack today - Eclipse and NetBeans. NetBeans? Seriously?! Where's IntelliJ IDEA? Does IntelliJ have a different way of debugging? I believe it's much more popular than NetBeans

Last I checked, IDEA is the most feature rich of the three debuggers as well. Besides normal support for breaking when a condition is true, you can instead set a breakpoint to log an expression (basically allowing you to do custom printlns without recompiling your code), setting dependent breakpoints (i.e. only activate this breakpoint after this other breakpoint has been hit; very useful for high-traffic areas of code), etc.

Re: Java Debugger – The Definitive List of Tools

#7

Post by AlisdairO »

peeters wrote: post #4
heapster wrote: post #2

> Main tools: In this category two tools lead the pack today - Eclipse and NetBeans. NetBeans? Seriously?! Where's IntelliJ IDEA? Does IntelliJ have a different way of debugging? I believe it's much more popular than NetBeans

Last I checked, IDEA is the most feature rich of the three debuggers as well. Besides normal support for breaking when a condition is true, you can instead set a breakpoint to log an expression (basically allowing you to do custom printlns without recompiling your code), setting dependent breakpoints (i.e. only activate this breakpoint after this other breakpoint has been hit; very useful for high-traffic areas of co…

> (i.e. only activate this breakpoint after this other breakpoint has been hit; very useful for high-traffic areas of code)

Wow, seeing that just completely sold me. I've been wanting that in eclipse for ages. Pity I won't be able to use it for work-work, just home-work :-)

Re: Java Debugger – The Definitive List of Tools

#8

Post by Sindisil »

heapster wrote: post #2

> Main tools: In this category two tools lead the pack today - Eclipse and NetBeans. NetBeans? Seriously?! Where's IntelliJ IDEA? Does IntelliJ have a different way of debugging? I believe it's much more popular than NetBeans

While I agree that IDEA absolutely should be in the list, I'm not sure that it's actually more popular out in the wild.

Eclipse, for all its many faults, is without a doubt the most popular. Sadly IMO, but not undeservedly. Network effects due to its early popularity have lead to Eclipse being capable of serving most any development need.

It would be interesting to see actual numbers (and I don't mean polls).

Certainly the proponents of IDEA are vocal, and for good reason, I think.

And certainly NetBeans, much like Java, has somewhat of a reputation in my circles for being slow, old, and lacking in features. Much like Java, that reputation is undeserved.

I bet it'd be a close race between IDEA and NetBeans, and wouldn't be surprised in the least if NetBeans had slightly higher overall use in industry.

Re: Java Debugger – The Definitive List of Tools

#9

Post by radd9er »

_JamesA_ wrote: post #6

There's no mention of YourKit[1] or jProfiler[2]. I'd really like to see an up to date in-depth comparison of those two tools including their respective licensing costs. [1]: http://yourkit.com/ [2]: http://www.ej-technologies.com/products/jprofiler/overview.h...

I am using yourkit (java swing apps) and finding it very powerful and useful in finding memory leaks, tracking down tough bugs. Which do you prefer? What type of apps to you develop? Im curious about profiling android apps, havent looked into if this is possible with yourkit.

Re: Java Debugger – The Definitive List of Tools

#10

Post by _JamesA_ »

radd9er wrote: post #9
_JamesA_ wrote: post #6

There's no mention of YourKit[1] or jProfiler[2]. I'd really like to see an up to date in-depth comparison of those two tools including their respective licensing costs. [1]: http://yourkit.com/ [2]: http://www.ej-technologies.com/products/jprofiler/overview.h...

I am using yourkit (java swing apps) and finding it very powerful and useful in finding memory leaks, tracking down tough bugs. Which do you prefer? What type of apps to you develop? Im curious about profiling android apps, havent looked into if this is possible with yourkit.

I've heard great things about YourKit but their web presence is amateurish.

The jProfiler site seems much more professional and informative. I can't help but wonder if that extends to the product and support as well.

The pricing, at least for single per-seat licensing, is almost identical.

I primarily develop server side applications and would really like to get a better insight into how that code is performing.

All of the reviews I have seen are pretty old and it seems both products have been heavily updated recently.

Why did you choose YourKit? Have you compared it with jProfiler?

Post reply on HN