Live data from Hacker News

No Bread, Beer or Biscuits: How I Lost 63lbs in 100 Days

chuff.it

1–10 of 123 posts

Re: No Bread, Beer or Biscuits: How I Lost 63lbs in 100 Days

#2
isn't that rapid? it sounds awesome (and congratulations), but i would perhaps check w a doctor or something that you're not losing weight too fast?

[edit: not to ask why you're losing weight so fast (because you're not eating, duh), but whether that rate is healthy.]

Re: No Bread, Beer or Biscuits: How I Lost 63lbs in 100 Days

#3
After attending hundreds of weight watchers meetings, and being involved with hundreds and hundreds of people losing a ton of weight, I still genuinely believe too many people make weight loss too complicated, which leads them to give up. Keep it simple (as the article did)

If you burn more calories (energy) than you eat, you will lose weight.

Obviously, you have choices. You can cut down on all the really high calorie stuff. You can increase your exercise to burn more. You can (ideally) do a bit of both.

Of the hundreds of people I've known that have lost life-changing amounts of weight, I would estimate less than 1% of them had any idea how calorie dense the foods they were eating (and drinking) every day really are.

For the majority of people that are severely overweight, all they have to do is cut out high calorie snacks like chips, soda and anything deep fried and they'll lose significant weight, without even getting off the couch.

Re: No Bread, Beer or Biscuits: How I Lost 63lbs in 100 Days

#4
While it's always great to hear success stories, I think the broader point of this post (and others like it) is that there's no "great secret" to weight loss. There's no silver bullet and certainly no short cut. The simple truth is: people in the western world eat crap and don't exercise.

The success stories all boil down to a few simple points: eat real food, cut down on alcohol, and do some exercise that you find enjoyable enough to do it every day.

Re: No Bread, Beer or Biscuits: How I Lost 63lbs in 100 Days

#5
I'm 31. A recent physical revealed that I have both high blood pressure and high cholesterol. They've put me on meds for the bp (which is now under control rather well) but they wanted me to try a lifestyle change before putting me on cholesterol meds. I was ~ 10 lbs overweight, nothing major - and while I wouldn't say I am fit by any means I wasn't out of shape either. But they wanted me to lose the 10 lbs and so they told me to stay under 2500mg of sodium per day, and less than 150g of carbs per day - no more than 50g per meal. And no red meat - all I can have meat wise basically is chicken, turkey and fish. Occasional lean pork.

I am two months into it - and have already lost 15 lbs, without any additional exercise. The carbs were rather easy to give up really - less sugar in my coffee, no pasta, few potatoes. Sodas were a little harder, but at 40g of sugar for a single Dr. Pepper, the choice between that or a whole sandwich is an easy one to make. The sodium is quite hard if not impossible though, unless you make every meal at home and only use fresh ingredients. If it is in a box, bag or can you can forget it. There is hardly anything at any restaurant you can get that is low sodium though. Even salads are absolutely loaded with sodium.

I will say I feel a little better, and not just from losing a couple inches around my waist. Water all day certainly helps. I don't think my cholesterol numbers are going anywhere really, I think my genetics are to blame, but I hope not.

Just a short anecdote, but if you sit behind a desk all day and have put on a few lbs, its fairly easy to give up the fast food and watch your carbs. It sure didn't seem like it at first though.

Re: No Bread, Beer or Biscuits: How I Lost 63lbs in 100 Days

#6

isn't that rapid? it sounds awesome (and congratulations), but i would perhaps check w a doctor or something that you're not losing weight too fast? [edit: not to ask why you're losing weight so fast (because you're not eating, duh), but whether that rate is healthy.]

If you start rapidly losing (or gaining) weight with no obvious explanation that is a cause for concern. If you start eating much less, and exercising much more, you probably don't need to ask a doctor why you're losing weight.

Re: No Bread, Beer or Biscuits: How I Lost 63lbs in 100 Days

#7
Interesting. A few months ago I was really ill one day. The night before I had drank heavily, but I think in this case I also got food poisoning from something. Anyway, I vowed to stop drinking that day, and have. What I realized is how much alcohol was affecting me. Even two days after drinking, I feel tired, less enthusiastic and more depressed. What I have found is that now I can exercise routinely (for several months now), where as before I would give up after a few days or weeks of trying. I think it's important for everyone to evaluate what in their lives may be holding them back, even if they don't realize it. Also, want to point out that I am not advocating everyone stop drinking, just that it seems alcohol affects me more so than others.

Re: No Bread, Beer or Biscuits: How I Lost 63lbs in 100 Days

#8

While it's always great to hear success stories, I think the broader point of this post (and others like it) is that there's no "great secret" to weight loss. There's no silver bullet and certainly no short cut. The simple truth is: people in the western world eat crap and don't exercise. The success stories all boil down to a few simple points: eat real food, cut down on alcohol, and do some exercise that you find e…

Agreed, this story is as much about self-motivation and determination as it is about weight loss techniques. They both go hand in hand. I saw myself at 192 and didn't like that number, so I got myself down to 174 after a year and maintain that weight. It's not a huge difference in size, but I feel better because of it. I also learned the value of staying away from bad habits, like junk food and sedentary activities.

Re: No Bread, Beer or Biscuits: How I Lost 63lbs in 100 Days

#9
post #6

isn't that rapid? it sounds awesome (and congratulations), but i would perhaps check w a doctor or something that you're not losing weight too fast? [edit: not to ask why you're losing weight so fast (because you're not eating, duh), but whether that rate is healthy.]

If you start rapidly losing (or gaining) weight with no obvious explanation that is a cause for concern. If you start eating much less, and exercising much more, you probably don't need to ask a doctor why you're losing weight.

I believe that the healthy rate is around 1 lbs per week with 2 lbs pushing it.
Post reply on HN