Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: FitDishes - nutrition-oriented local search

fitdishes.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

1–7 of 7 posts

Re: Show HN: FitDishes - nutrition-oriented local search

#3

Post by milohoffman »

jdludlow wrote: post #2

I like where this could go, but basing it on calories isn't particularly useful. 300 calories of garbage (or corn syrup if you will) is still eating garbage.

Thanks for the feedback! Totally agree that calories != nutritional value.

Farther out, the plan is to allow users to conduct structured searches along all dimensions of menu items - macro-nutrients, sodium, etc. Due to the limitations of one of the APIs I'm using, I can only support a calorie parameter in queries for now. Note that once you drill into a particular menu item, you are provided with in-depth nutritional data like carbohydrates, protein, and fat.

Re: Show HN: FitDishes - nutrition-oriented local search

#4

Post by boards2x »

jdludlow wrote: post #2

I like where this could go, but basing it on calories isn't particularly useful. 300 calories of garbage (or corn syrup if you will) is still eating garbage.

ie McDonald and Burger King show up in results for default search. That's very misleading, unless you don't mind pinkslime as food.

Re: Show HN: FitDishes - nutrition-oriented local search

#6

Post by milohoffman »

boards2x wrote: post #4
jdludlow wrote: post #2

I like where this could go, but basing it on calories isn't particularly useful. 300 calories of garbage (or corn syrup if you will) is still eating garbage.

ie McDonald and Burger King show up in results for default search. That's very misleading, unless you don't mind pinkslime as food.

The search identifies venues with dishes that match your query and calorie criteria, and then sorts those venues based on distance, which is why McDonald's and Burger King will often show up first. Once we're able to support other search parameters (e.g., putting a limit on the grams of fat or the % of calories contributed by fat), the fast food results should filter out - or at least he "pinkslime" ones :). Another feature on the roadmap is providing some summary (e.g., a grade or score) of the nutritional value of a menu item - this score would factor in things beyond calories like macro-nutrient breakdowns and might help prevent "misleading" results.

In the meantime, the hope is that calories are useful as a jumping off point when it comes to discovering healthy dishes nearby, and as I mentioned before you can see the full nutritional info by clicking on a particular item.

Post reply on HN