Live data from Hacker News

Poll: How many homeschoolers/unschoolers here? When did you start?

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 38 posts

Poll: How many homeschoolers/unschoolers here? When did you start?

#1
Considering homeschooling for my kids (4 and 7) when we move to Virginia. We have the best in the city of New Orleans and getting to the same level in Virginia seems prohibitive. My wife and I are deep in the research phase, reading, talking with people, conference in June, etc. Would like to get a sense of how many did it, and if you would share your thoughts, I'd appreciate it.

Re: Poll: How many homeschoolers/unschoolers here? When did you start?

#2
We educate at home (not "homeschool"--that implies schooling at home, and re-creating school at home is definitely not our goal), starting from the very beginning, all the way through high school.

We have 8 ranging from 25 down to 8, so it's still a big work in progress. ;-)

Some of our older kids have gone to (very demanding) colleges, others couldn't be bothered. Depends a lot on the person and his life goals and interests, of course.

Re: Poll: How many homeschoolers/unschoolers here? When did you start?

#3
i was homeschooled for a year in middle school as my family made the transition from private to public schools. the year of homeschooling allowed my parents to save some more money for a down payment on a house with good public schools. my brother was homeschooled at the same time - he is three years younger than me - for grade school.

I think home school is fine for primary school. once you get into middle and high school i am not as supportive. this may have been only my experience but i learn best when interacting with others - showing others what i learned and learning from others mistakes. this becomes more significant during middle school/high school as this is when more group tasks are assigned.

Re: Poll: How many homeschoolers/unschoolers here? When did you start?

#5
We've gone back and forth between homeschooling, private schools in Puerto Rico, and public schools in Indiana. This fall we'll be trying a new combination (a private school in Indiana).

Both school and home education have their strong points. If you have the time to do it, I recommend home education -- you'll never get your kids' childhood back, and there's no time more quality than teaching them all the good parts of the world.

You have to dance a lot harder, to make sure they have plenty of contact with people their own age. It's almost certain that there will be homeschooling groups in your new area in Virginia, so that takes care of that, depending on the vitality of the groups in question. But nowadays, in the States, it's not too hard to find social support networks for homeschoolers.

Re: Poll: How many homeschoolers/unschoolers here? When did you start?

#6

i was homeschooled for a year in middle school as my family made the transition from private to public schools. the year of homeschooling allowed my parents to save some more money for a down payment on a house with good public schools. my brother was homeschooled at the same time - he is three years younger than me - for grade school. I think home school is fine for primary school. once you get into middle and high…

> I think home school is fine for primary school. once you get into middle and high school i am not as supportive.

Interesting. My thoughts are nearly the reverse.

We home-schooled one kid for one year (1st grade [U.S. terminology]), when we had some problems with the public schools, and then put them in public school for all the rest of it. We are considering starting up home-schooling for all of them some time in the middle/high school years, since that is when peer influences can become problematic, and sometimes dangerous.

Re: Poll: How many homeschoolers/unschoolers here? When did you start?

#7
I figured school and I weren't a right fit some time in high school, so I dropped out then. Never even heard of unschooling at the time, I just considered myself an autodidact. That was now more than two years ago, and I still haven't started "unschooling" myself.

It was a problem when my parents threw me out soon after my 18th birthday, for dropping out of school. I had to get a miserable job, coding PHP for about the same amount of money my friend got stacking boxes in a warehouse. That was nothing unexpected, it just shows how much programmers are valued in my country.

The job made me depressed, unable to do anything. Not learn, nothing.

Now I'm working with a friend on a startup company, poised to solve all our problems, but I wouldn't say that's going so great either.

But I don't regret anything. School wasn't a good way of learning for me, and I will continue my education on my own, as soon as this company gets of the ground and I have some time.

Re: Poll: How many homeschoolers/unschoolers here? When did you start?

#8
I read the question as the OP wanting comments from people who were homeschooled, not parents who are homeschooling. I think this is very wise. I am not trying to make any particular point for or against; just that what parents think worked with their kids, and what kids think their parents did that worked is not always the same thing.

Re: Poll: How many homeschoolers/unschoolers here? When did you start?

#9
My 3 kids started taking classes at the local community colleges while in high school, especially math. This was CA and they could take the classes for high school credit or college, even UC, credit. They opted for UC credit and it put them ahead of the game. My daughter avoided a 5th year at UCLA. My son dropped out of college and eventually founded a company with a couple of friends.

Re: Poll: How many homeschoolers/unschoolers here? When did you start?

#10

i was homeschooled for a year in middle school as my family made the transition from private to public schools. the year of homeschooling allowed my parents to save some more money for a down payment on a house with good public schools. my brother was homeschooled at the same time - he is three years younger than me - for grade school. I think home school is fine for primary school. once you get into middle and high…

> I think home school is fine for primary school. once you get into middle and high school i am not as supportive. Interesting. My thoughts are nearly the reverse. We home-schooled one kid for one year (1st grade [U.S. terminology]), when we had some problems with the public schools, and then put them in public school for all the rest of it. We are considering starting up home-schooling for all of them some time in t…

Peer influences will inevitably be problematic and dangerous throughout the course of one's lifetime. If a teenager doesn't learn how to handle these influences in high school, then the dangers will invariably be exacerbated in adulthood.
Post reply on HN