Live data from Hacker News

To All the White Girls Who Didn't Get into the College of their Dreams

racialicious.com

1–10 of 20 posts

Re: To All the White Girls Who Didn't Get into the College of their Dreams

#4
Re: Suzy Lee Weiss ("And then there’s Suzy Lee Weiss who claims a 4.5 GPA, a 2120 SAT score, and spot as a US Senate Page.")

You don't need to blame affirmative action for that rejection. 2120 (~1410 on the older scale for people my age) was Duke/Cornell numbers back when I was applying to colleges a dozen years ago, and these days it's Berkely/Michigan/Virginia numbers. That's the nature of a system where populations grow but class sizes stay the same at top colleges. The other stuff is meaningless--you can easily inflate your way to a 4.0+ GPA these days now that schools have eagerly rushed to label everything AP, and being a Senate page just means you know a Senator (your parents being rich and living in D.C. is enough) .

I can't believe this kid got on T.V.

Re: To All the White Girls Who Didn't Get into the College of their Dreams

#6
A terrible title for a reasonably good article.

It does underemphasize how much getting into a specific school is kind of a lottery even for the highly qualified. I knew plenty of people who applied to pretty much every top school, and got into some small number of them -- in some cases including their first choice. My sister applied to a bunch of highly ranked schools -- many rejected her, but she made it into Yale.

The somewhat arbitrary & capricious nature of admissions is part of what feeds into this whole complex the article discusses.

Re: To All the White Girls Who Didn't Get into the College of their Dreams

#8

A terrible title for a reasonably good article. It does underemphasize how much getting into a specific school is kind of a lottery even for the highly qualified. I knew plenty of people who applied to pretty much every top school, and got into some small number of them -- in some cases including their first choice. My sister applied to a bunch of highly ranked schools -- many rejected her, but she made it into Yale.…

I think it's a play on Suzy's op-ed "To (All) the Colleges That Rejected Me".

Re: To All the White Girls Who Didn't Get into the College of their Dreams

#9
post #8

A terrible title for a reasonably good article. It does underemphasize how much getting into a specific school is kind of a lottery even for the highly qualified. I knew plenty of people who applied to pretty much every top school, and got into some small number of them -- in some cases including their first choice. My sister applied to a bunch of highly ranked schools -- many rejected her, but she made it into Yale.…

I think it's a play on Suzy's op-ed "To (All) the Colleges That Rejected Me".

Ah, that makes more sense now.

Re: To All the White Girls Who Didn't Get into the College of their Dreams

#10
post #7

> but why would anyone want to admit a student who comes off as entitled, smarmy, ignorant, and racist? The author might find the reason for her non-admission to Brown there. The piece has some good ideas, but the racism is dialed up a bit high in there.

Ok, point to something specifically racist.
Post reply on HN