Live data from Hacker News

It Still Can't Do My Job: Four Years of Moving Goalposts (2022–2026)

publicznyprofil.github.io

1–10 of 143 posts

Re: It Still Can't Do My Job: Four Years of Moving Goalposts (2022–2026)

#3
I think this is true of "AGI" too.

AI is already better than us at a bunch of things, and worse at a few. The list of things it's better than us at increases every month.

In 5 years, people will still be saying "Well, I can still ride a unicycle blindfolded better than a robot so it's not AGI."

AGI is such a meaningless term and puts too much importance on human-level intelligence.

Re: It Still Can't Do My Job: Four Years of Moving Goalposts (2022–2026)

#4
You should add a parallel timeline of how many times AI CEOs have claimed their next model is too dangerous to release, AGI is months away, or some white collar job will be obsolete within 6 months.

I don’t know anyone in the tech industry who thinks AGI will never happen or that software engineering and white collar jobs can’t be automated. We all read sci fi, you’re not some unique visionary for anticipating AI. The frustration is with how much the claims have outpaced reality and how poorly the investors and executives have treated their workers during this transition.

Re: It Still Can't Do My Job: Four Years of Moving Goalposts (2022–2026)

#7
post #3

I think this is true of "AGI" too. AI is already better than us at a bunch of things, and worse at a few. The list of things it's better than us at increases every month. In 5 years, people will still be saying "Well, I can still ride a unicycle blindfolded better than a robot so it's not AGI." AGI is such a meaningless term and puts too much importance on human-level intelligence.

I am pretty convinced modern LLMs are AGIs based on the pelicans and ability to write music in MIDI.

Re: It Still Can't Do My Job: Four Years of Moving Goalposts (2022–2026)

#8
post #3

I think this is true of "AGI" too. AI is already better than us at a bunch of things, and worse at a few. The list of things it's better than us at increases every month. In 5 years, people will still be saying "Well, I can still ride a unicycle blindfolded better than a robot so it's not AGI." AGI is such a meaningless term and puts too much importance on human-level intelligence.

> "Well, I can still ride a unicycle blindfolded better than a robot so it's not AGI."

Can you though? I've seen some videos recently of some pretty darn scary Chinese robots that I suspect might already be capable of riding a unicycle blindfolded if someone set 'em on that task. ;)

Re: It Still Can't Do My Job: Four Years of Moving Goalposts (2022–2026)

#9
post #3

I think this is true of "AGI" too. AI is already better than us at a bunch of things, and worse at a few. The list of things it's better than us at increases every month. In 5 years, people will still be saying "Well, I can still ride a unicycle blindfolded better than a robot so it's not AGI." AGI is such a meaningless term and puts too much importance on human-level intelligence.

> "Well, I can still ride a unicycle blindfolded better than a robot so it's not AGI." Can you though? I've seen some videos recently of some pretty darn scary Chinese robots that I suspect might already be capable of riding a unicycle blindfolded if someone set 'em on that task. ;)

I can't even ride a bike so I got AGI'd about a decade ago

Re: It Still Can't Do My Job: Four Years of Moving Goalposts (2022–2026)

#10

You should add a parallel timeline of how many times AI CEOs have claimed their next model is too dangerous to release, AGI is months away, or some white collar job will be obsolete within 6 months. I don’t know anyone in the tech industry who thinks AGI will never happen or that software engineering and white collar jobs can’t be automated. We all read sci fi, you’re not some unique visionary for anticipating AI. Th…

Literally every CEO AI or otherwise claims bullshit about their product. It's their job. It's got nothing to do with people actually using something and not coming to terms with it having any value. If you've never seen a screwdriver it's a waste of time compared to nails.
Post reply on HN