Live data from Hacker News

Deep under Antarctic ice, a long-predicted cosmic whisper breaks through

phys.org

1–10 of 47 posts

Re: Deep under Antarctic ice, a long-predicted cosmic whisper breaks through

#3
Summary for those who won't fight through four blocking pop-ups to read the article:

When a high-energy particle (cosmic ray, say) hits ice, it creates an interaction cascade. (Think of what the Fly's Eye experiment sees, but in ice.) That interaction cascade creates (among other things) a radio signal. This detector is a radio detector under Antarctic ice, looking for exactly that.

The point is that, if a high-energy neutrino were to hit the ice, it could create the same kind of cascade, but it would make it much further into the ice. By having multiple detectors, they can pin down the location, and so they can try to tell the difference between "regular" cosmic rays and high-energy neutrinos.

The detector seems to be functioning as designed. They have seven candidate neutrino interactions.

Re: Deep under Antarctic ice, a long-predicted cosmic whisper breaks through

#5
post #4

Is it just ice? I thought most neutrino detectors were large underground pools of water. I mean ... tomāto/tomăto, yes, but is solid water better than liquid water?

The size of the detector can be very large, stable, and protected with an ice cap. https://icecube.wisc.edu/science/icecube/

There aren't a lot of places with multiple km of water without things like animal life or other confounders.

Re: Deep under Antarctic ice, a long-predicted cosmic whisper breaks through

#6

Summary for those who won't fight through four blocking pop-ups to read the article: When a high-energy particle (cosmic ray, say) hits ice, it creates an interaction cascade. (Think of what the Fly's Eye experiment sees, but in ice.) That interaction cascade creates (among other things) a radio signal. This detector is a radio detector under Antarctic ice, looking for exactly that. The point is that, if a high-energ…

I just turned off my ad blocker to see how bad it is. Because with it turned on I didn't see any popups.

They have Google ads on their site promoting a paid ad free version of their site? WTF? Why would you pay google to put ads for on your site for your own service?

Re: Deep under Antarctic ice, a long-predicted cosmic whisper breaks through

#9
post #5
post #4

Is it just ice? I thought most neutrino detectors were large underground pools of water. I mean ... tomāto/tomăto, yes, but is solid water better than liquid water?

The size of the detector can be very large, stable, and protected with an ice cap. https://icecube.wisc.edu/science/icecube/ There aren't a lot of places with multiple km of water without things like animal life or other confounders.

So, [controlled] liquid water is better but [controlled] solid water is more abundant?
Post reply on HN