Live data from Hacker News

Death Note: L, Anonymity and Eluding Entropy (2011)

gwern.net

1–10 of 24 posts

Re: Death Note: L, Anonymity and Eluding Entropy (2011)

#2
Related. Others?

Death Note: L, Anonymity and Eluding Entropy - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26826585 - April 2021 (10 comments)

Death Note: L, Anonymity and Eluding Entropy (2017) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20617325 - Aug 2019 (139 comments)

Death Note Anonymity: L, Anonymity and Eluding Entropy - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9553494 - May 2015 (23 comments)

Who wrote the 'Death Note' script? - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5010846 - Jan 2013 (79 comments)

Re: Death Note: L, Anonymity and Eluding Entropy (2011)

#4
I would highly recommend the 2006 deaths note films.

I found the manga and anime to have too many side stories. Fans of them love these near miss stories, but I found them like a bunch of dead ends.

The double feature is well made and much more focused on the core story, imho

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_Note_(2006_film)

Re: Death Note: L, Anonymity and Eluding Entropy (2011)

#5

I would highly recommend the 2006 deaths note films. I found the manga and anime to have too many side stories. Fans of them love these near miss stories, but I found them like a bunch of dead ends. The double feature is well made and much more focused on the core story, imho https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_Note_(2006_film)

I also thought the the L spin-off was pretty good.

Re: Death Note: L, Anonymity and Eluding Entropy (2011)

#6
The analysis forgets the very first problem after someone is killing criminals visibly: Light relies on TV to find them. You could tell it's Japan without doing any math about time zones or anythING, as TV itself brings in the bias. To pretend you are elsewhere, you have to be consuming foreign news to even begin to have a chance to hide yourself

Re: Death Note: L, Anonymity and Eluding Entropy (2011)

#8

> How much positive evidence for guilt is necessary before we decide that some man should be put away? Isn’t this what “beyond a reasonable doubt” is doing? It’s obviously not precise but it’s an intention of the current system.

> How much positive evidence for guilt is necessary before we decide that some man should be put away?

The answer to this question is ZERO. We are human, after all (and the corollary is that no amount of evidence will tip the scale for someone we don't want to put away). How much positive evidence for guilt ought to be necessary for a society to remain moral/egalitarian/equitable is a different question entirely.

Re: Death Note: L, Anonymity and Eluding Entropy (2011)

#9

> How much positive evidence for guilt is necessary before we decide that some man should be put away? Isn’t this what “beyond a reasonable doubt” is doing? It’s obviously not precise but it’s an intention of the current system.

> How much positive evidence for guilt is necessary before we decide that some man should be put away? The answer to this question is ZERO. We are human, after all (and the corollary is that no amount of evidence will tip the scale for someone we don't want to put away). How much positive evidence for guilt ought to be necessary for a society to remain moral/egalitarian/equitable is a different question entirely.

Zero evidence is required to lock someone up?

Re: Death Note: L, Anonymity and Eluding Entropy (2011)

#10

I would highly recommend the 2006 deaths note films. I found the manga and anime to have too many side stories. Fans of them love these near miss stories, but I found them like a bunch of dead ends. The double feature is well made and much more focused on the core story, imho https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_Note_(2006_film)

They're not dead ends per se because their purpose is growing the characters and revealing more of them to the audience. The movie streamlines and speed runs all that, for better or worse.
Post reply on HN