Live data from Hacker News

White House Posts Altered Photo Showing Arrested Minnesota Protester Crying

nytimes.com

1–10 of 52 posts

Re: White House Posts Altered Photo Showing Arrested Minnesota Protester Crying

#4
Having the government manipulate mass-media material is frankly insane.

Everyone involved in something like this should be sacked immediately, but I have very little hope that voters are going to punish egregious misbehavior like this as long as it's "their" side doing it.

If you had told republican voters in 2016 that within the decade, there were going to be widespread searches/arrests by federal agents without warrant or trial, unapologetic image falsification by the White House and even killings of unarmed civilian protesters: They would have gone absolutely ballistic- rightfully so.

Re: White House Posts Altered Photo Showing Arrested Minnesota Protester Crying

#5
Honestly, this should give hope for people worried about it. Not the fact that it was done, but the fact that the New York Times immediately posts about it. That's about the best you can ask for now that this tech is ubiquitous and not going back in the can.

Re: White House Posts Altered Photo Showing Arrested Minnesota Protester Crying

#6
During France’s Reign of Terror, executions by guillotine were public. It was considered distinguished for victims to go stoically, and many did, which left the crowds to have their fun.

I recall, however, and this may be apocryphal, that one woman went to the stand screaming and crying and begging for mercy. This humanized her. The crowds, soured to their revelry, went home.

I am curious if her pleas were heard because those people were better than we are today, or because social media amplifies our cruelty beyond even that of our darkest modern histories.

Re: White House Posts Altered Photo Showing Arrested Minnesota Protester Crying

#7
> “Enforcement of the law will continue. The memes will continue.”

The Whitehouse thinks digitally altering photos of people it arrests is a "meme"?

That's just as perverted an understanding of a "meme" as their understanding of "law". Namely: the law protects but does but bind the in-group, and binds but does not protect those in the out-group. Thus the January 6 insurrectionists get pardons, and the killer of Renee Good has the automatic internal investigation cancelled.

"Meme" my ass.

Re: White House Posts Altered Photo Showing Arrested Minnesota Protester Crying

#8
I just thought of a crazy analogy. I was on the internet in the mid 90's, using gopher and usenet, etc. It was great then because only the smart people knew how to get on. Then in the mid 00's it all went to sht.

Now we come to graphic design. It used to be only smart people knew how to use photoshop to manipulate images, but now we have given any idiot the power to manipulate images with AI and this is where we are.

Re: White House Posts Altered Photo Showing Arrested Minnesota Protester Crying

#9
post #4

Having the government manipulate mass-media material is frankly insane. Everyone involved in something like this should be sacked immediately, but I have very little hope that voters are going to punish egregious misbehavior like this as long as it's "their" side doing it. If you had told republican voters in 2016 that within the decade, there were going to be widespread searches/arrests by federal agents without war…

No, they wouldn't, because they didn't care when this happened during Trump's first term, Trump said this would happen during his 2nd term, AND THEY STILL VOTED FOR HIM.

This is what America voted for.

Re: White House Posts Altered Photo Showing Arrested Minnesota Protester Crying

#10
post #4

Having the government manipulate mass-media material is frankly insane. Everyone involved in something like this should be sacked immediately, but I have very little hope that voters are going to punish egregious misbehavior like this as long as it's "their" side doing it. If you had told republican voters in 2016 that within the decade, there were going to be widespread searches/arrests by federal agents without war…

[deleted]
Post reply on HN