Live data from Hacker News

Verifying your Matrix devices is becoming mandatory

element.io

1–10 of 251 posts

Re: Verifying your Matrix devices is becoming mandatory

#4
post #3

What is verification? What does it involve doing? A lot of information on why it's useful, but how is it implemented? I hope it's not something like the Play Integrity API, but with no information to go on, I can't say either way.

Yeah, I was wondering this as well. At the very least, this appears to be an Element requirement that was just enabled by a Matrix protocol update, so moving would be possible, but afaik Element is extremely popular as far as Matrix goes.

Re: Verifying your Matrix devices is becoming mandatory

#5
post #3

What is verification? What does it involve doing? A lot of information on why it's useful, but how is it implemented? I hope it's not something like the Play Integrity API, but with no information to go on, I can't say either way.

In the current state, it's basically just a self verification. When you use a new device it shows a series of emoji on each device and asks you if they're the same, then the device is verified.

Re: Verifying your Matrix devices is becoming mandatory

#6
Is this the ritual of getting together with a person and checking that their fingerprint match what you see on the app?

If this is that case what will happen is that people will start verifying everyone (because they might want to text to strangers that they can't bother verifying because the stakes are so low) and so verification will lose all meaning.

Re: Verifying your Matrix devices is becoming mandatory

#7
post #3

What is verification? What does it involve doing? A lot of information on why it's useful, but how is it implemented? I hope it's not something like the Play Integrity API, but with no information to go on, I can't say either way.

https://element.io/en/help#encryption-device-verification

> After Alice logs in on a new device, she uses her cryptographic identity to demonstrate to Bob that the new device genuinely belongs to her, rather than being added by someone else with access to her account. She can do this either by entering her recovery key (which gives the new device immediate access to her cryptographic identity ), or by carrying out an interactive verification from an existing verified device.

Re: Verifying your Matrix devices is becoming mandatory

#8
post #3

What is verification? What does it involve doing? A lot of information on why it's useful, but how is it implemented? I hope it's not something like the Play Integrity API, but with no information to go on, I can't say either way.

In the current state, it's basically just a self verification. When you use a new device it shows a series of emoji on each device and asks you if they're the same, then the device is verified.

You can also use a generated security key to verify as a type of second-factor.
Post reply on HN