Live data from Hacker News

American science to soon face its largest brain drain in history

bigthink.com

1–10 of 129 posts

Re: American science to soon face its largest brain drain in history

#4
> Many of the most valuable scientific organizations in the world, including NOAA, NASA, the NSF, the CDC, the EPA, and the FDA,

I don’t dismiss the premise of the article and I think it is a shame how these organizations are being impacted, but I don’t know that these are the best exemplars of cutting edge science being shut down that will lead to America’s downfall from its scientific perch.

Re: American science to soon face its largest brain drain in history

#6

This is good for the world. Hyper concentration of talent reduces diversity.

Diversity of what (identity or thought), who, and/or where?

Silicon Valley, the population of ordinary people residing there, 10 years ago (2015), heaved diversity. In corporate employment, it took decades to break through gender and race ceilings in industry to various degrees, but it largely happened, mostly, for better or worse.

Bringing together people, capital, opportunity, and academia creates a vibrant ecosystem that mutually reinforces further gains in a "virtuous" cycle. What doesn't create much is having only a few people spread out without a support system. It takes encouraging a mix of many open minded people within a smaller physical or digital proximity in order to get the w00w00 effect. That can't really happen when people are told they're not welcome.

Re: American science to soon face its largest brain drain in history

#9
post #7

This is good for the world. Hyper concentration of talent reduces diversity.

Counterpoint: concentration of talent is incredibly valuable for humankind.

They're concentrating in China. It's just that the US won't be that location of talent.

Re: American science to soon face its largest brain drain in history

#10

> Many of the most valuable scientific organizations in the world, including NOAA, NASA, the NSF, the CDC, the EPA, and the FDA, I don’t dismiss the premise of the article and I think it is a shame how these organizations are being impacted, but I don’t know that these are the best exemplars of cutting edge science being shut down that will lead to America’s downfall from its scientific perch.

Isn't it true though that they, altogether, fund America's exemplars of cutting edge science? Like, isn't that the point?
Post reply on HN