Live data from Hacker News

Web Translator API

developer.mozilla.org

1–10 of 71 posts

Re: Web Translator API

#3
While this might be useful, be mindful:

- it's experimental

- the "specification" is nowhere near a standards track: https://webmachinelearning.github.io/translation-api/

Of course it's already shipped in Chrome, and now Chrome pretends that its own Chrome-only API is somehow standard. Expect people on HN to blame other browsers for not shipping this.

Re: Web Translator API

#5
post #2

You had me at "Browser compatibility".

Chrome embeds a small LLM (never stops being a funny thing) in the browser allowing them to do local translations.

I assume every browser will do the same as on-device models start becoming more useful.

Re: Web Translator API

#6
post #5
post #2

You had me at "Browser compatibility".

Chrome embeds a small LLM (never stops being a funny thing) in the browser allowing them to do local translations. I assume every browser will do the same as on-device models start becoming more useful.

While I appreciate the on-device approach for a couple of reasons, it is rather ironic that Mozilla needs to document that for them.

Re: Web Translator API

#7
post #6
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Chrome embeds a small LLM (never stops being a funny thing) in the browser allowing them to do local translations. I assume every browser will do the same as on-device models start becoming more useful.

While I appreciate the on-device approach for a couple of reasons, it is rather ironic that Mozilla needs to document that for them.

Firefox also has on-device translations for what its worth.

Re: Web Translator API

#8
Can we please NOT autotranslate the web? I have yet to find a site where the quality of autotranslate does not make me stop using that site. I was already irritated when google started to show me de.wikipedia.org articles adespite me explicitly searching for the english article name. Then came Etsy, where the autotranslate quality was so bad I stopped using the site altogether.

Re: Web Translator API

#9
post #5
post #2

You had me at "Browser compatibility".

Chrome embeds a small LLM (never stops being a funny thing) in the browser allowing them to do local translations. I assume every browser will do the same as on-device models start becoming more useful.

What's the easiest way to get this functionality outside of the browser, e.g. as a CLI tool?

Last time I looked I wasn't able to find any easy to run models that supported more than a handful of languages.

Post reply on HN