Live data from Hacker News

Web designs are getting too complicated

websmith.studio

1–10 of 83 posts

Re: Web designs are getting too complicated

#5
post #3

Many web pages are impossible to read without ad-blockers, Safari Reader, or whatever Firefox does to print (to pdf). I've tried other readability extensions and they didn't satisfy.

Firefox has a reader mode. It does not work on every site, probably because on some sites it can't decide where it's the content. Examples with Firefox nightly on Android: it works on the site this thread is about, it does not work on HN.

Re: Web designs are getting too complicated

#8

”Yet here we are - the average website now weighs around 2.5MB according to HTTP Archive. That's heavier than the original Doom game.”

And so little is delivered with the 2.5mb. Worrying more that so much traffic is bot traffic, and bloating sites becomes significantly wasted resources.

Re: Web designs are getting too complicated

#9
> Let's be honest: you're designing to impress other designers, not users. And that's the problem.

I've referred to this as "CV driven development". Although to be fair that developer that designs a microservice architecture for 50 users is not better either.

But on the whole, I don't agree with the title. My feeling is - overall - pages have become a lot less gimmicky than they used to be.

Re: Web designs are getting too complicated

#10

Oi designers? You mean oi enshittifing CTOs?

My experience is that CTOs don't care about animations, rounded corners, or what not - they care about metrics. These artsy bullshit layouts are suggested by design teams and the technical side either doesn't care/is content to delegate or there's someone at director level who wants to be the next Steve Jobs and empowers design.

This isn't to say that all design is bad - good design is hard and most software engineers are really bad at it and undervalue its impact on users - but if you blindly trust design you can end up with garbage like what this article talks about.

Post reply on HN